PolishForums LIVE  /  Archives [3]    
   
Posts by mafketis  

Joined: 31 Mar 2008 / Male ♂
Warnings: 1 - O
Last Post: 22 Nov 2024
Threads: Total: 38 / In This Archive: 19
Posts: Total: 10991 / In This Archive: 4201
From: tez nie
Speaks Polish?: tak
Interests: tez nie

Displayed posts: 4220 / page 6 of 141
sort: Latest first   Oldest first   |
mafketis   
8 Jul 2019
Language / Myśląc "Polska" - Does new PiS motto.... really mean anything? [20]

Okay.....

perfect-english-grammar.com/stative-verbs.html

stative verb 'think' can be used in the continuous in American

"I'm thinking they're too young to get married." sounds perfectly normal to me.

maybe this is an emerging distinction between American and other varieties... "I'm lovin' it" didn't sound that bad to me, instead it had an informal layer of extra emotion. I would agree that it probably wasn't a good idea to use it in other places where it wouldn't have that meaning.
mafketis   
8 Jul 2019
Language / Myśląc "Polska" - Does new PiS motto.... really mean anything? [20]

as opposed to the correct infinitive form in "I love it."

there is no infinitive in "I love it", I'm fairly sure that "I'm lovin' it" comes from AAVE (African American Vernacular English) which often uses continuous forms with habitual/intensive meanings.

The fact that the slogan is purely false is another matter

I'm assuming that "Kasa za głosy" would be a bit too obvious...
mafketis   
8 Jul 2019
Language / Myśląc "Polska" - Does new PiS motto.... really mean anything? [20]

Okay, I'm stumped. The new motto for PiS is "Myśląc Polska" which kind of... doesn't make any sense?

The form myśląc is an adverbial participle (which must share a subject with a following finite verb). An English example might be: "Reading the report, the director began sobbing." (Czytając raport kierownik zaczął szlochać) here 'reading' and 'began' have the same subject 'the director'.

The problem here is the "Myśląc Polska" puts Poland (Polska) in the subject position for some finite verb to follow "Thinking, Poland [did/does/will do X]" and I can't figure out how people are supposed to finish the sentence...

I asked one native speaker (Phd in a non-language related field) and he just said it was probably supposed to sound 'poetic' but couldn't pin down what exactly was meant.

Anyone here have any ideas about what (if anything) the phrase is supposed to mean?
mafketis   
6 Jul 2019
UK, Ireland / Polish traffickers in the UK jailed for enslaving hundreds of their own people [58]

When and where do you see Polish gypsies? A couple look a bit like there might be some gypsy ancestry but generally no, they don't like the gypsies that you see in Poland...

Granted there are cases where gypsy criminals in WEurope get labelled by citizenship rather than ethnic group (especially from Slovakia and Lithuania it seems) but in this case I don't see it (and I've had gypsy neighbors and used to live in a part of town where they were more concentrated)

e3.365dm.com/19/07/1600x900/skynews-slavery-gang-polish_4710564.jpg?20190705125251
mafketis   
5 Jul 2019
UK, Ireland / Polish traffickers in the UK jailed for enslaving hundreds of their own people [58]

Wasn't they gypsies? At least most of them?>

There seems to be some gypsy involvement but at least half of the defendants don't look like gypsies (to me)

There is no shortage of scuzzy bottom feeder Poles eager to rip off their countrymen... lock them up and throw away the key!
mafketis   
27 Jun 2019
Language / Looking for meaning of a phrase ("Yatz Gatz Spetagamie") [47]

, Jews were so segregated, so isolated from mainstream society for ever so long, Christians couldn't look upon them as "Poles"

But did Jews want to be looked upon as "Poles"? It does take two to tango...
mafketis   
25 Jun 2019
Life / Everything this guy says I feel about Poland [69]

A Pole will often come and stand right next to you

Personal space is sometimes physical and sometimes mental.... Polish people are mostly pretty good at staying out of the latter even if they don't pay much attention to the former. One place they might want to pay attention the physical space is when they're walking by themselves in a secluded spot with their own thoughts which don't include greetings and/or small talk...
mafketis   
24 Jun 2019
Life / Everything this guy says I feel about Poland [69]

According to natural human instincts which are to interact with other humans

See... this is where doug misses things in his blind fury that Polish people don't act like Brits all the time. There is an interaction that's subtle (but real) but based on keeping your distance and not infringing on the other person's personal space (when they may well wish to be alone with their thoughts rather than pretending to be long lost acquaintances).

When in Rome.... (I guess Doug and your version completes that with 'insist that Romans do it just like you did at home, dammit!)

Thinking in British or American or GErman terms (and expecting British or French or Danish behavior) while living in Poland is the least productive strategy possible....

Complain in private to friends, but maintain some dignity in public while you're learning how things work locally.
mafketis   
24 Jun 2019
Life / Everything this guy says I feel about Poland [69]

but it's basic manners and common courtesy to 'salute' as we say in Ireland, a stranger ... such as the beach

According to who? Poles might well perceive it as getting in their faces and forcing your presence on them... co kraj to obyczaj...

After a few years most people learn to deal with a foreign country as it is (and not as a deformed version of their home country).
mafketis   
24 Jun 2019
Life / Everything this guy says I feel about Poland [69]

I've said it before and I'll say it again, the British (far more than other peopels IME) are driven to anger (or even blind rage) at norms of behavior that are different from their own....

And it's only (some) long time Brits in Poland who are perversely proud of their poor knowledge of Polish....
mafketis   
10 Jun 2019
Language / Pronunciation question: ę at the end of a sentence [5]

I think the ę at the end of sentence should not, or at least need not, be nasalized. B

There's a fair amount of variation in how people pronounced ę at the end of a word. Most speakers most of the time pronounce it exactly as e, but most speakers do have some kind of nasal sound at times especially in certain words and positions... As far as I know no one has carefully studied this.

My impression is that nasalization is a bit more common around breaks in speech (at the end of sentences) and when otherwise the first and third person verb forms would be the same (piszę vs pisze) and się when it's a bit emphasized. I have the idea that the feminine accusative ending is nasalized less often.

In more formal contexts nasalization is a lot more frequent. It's also common 'spelling pronunciations' where ę is pronounced... like ę in the middle of the word (pronouncing będę instead of the usual spoken pronunciation (bende)

Some years ago I translated a paper by a well-known Polish phonetician who said (paraphrasing) that never nasalizing final ę sounds too colloquial and always nasalizing it sounds artificially formal and the best style is to nasalize some and not nasalize others... (but with no info about which to nasalize).
mafketis   
6 Jun 2019
Language / The rule determining pronunciation of " sprawdź " in the Polish language [3]

@mhurwicz

in final position dź sounds like ć (which causes the w to be pronounced like f).

all consonants with voiceless equivalents (b, d, g, dż, dź etc) are devoiced in final position (are pronounced like p, t, k, cz, ć etc)

in connected speech they aren't devoiced if the next words begins with a voiced consonant.

there's also a kind of spelling pronunciation where the the voicing might be retained but this is used only in isolation (or to let someone know how the word is written).

don't worry too much about voicing assimilation yet, a lot of it comes naturally once you know the basic principle
mafketis   
4 Jun 2019
Travel / Poland in photo riddles [3134]

Judging by the colors.... Wrocław? (I seem to recall blue trams there) unlike the red used in Warsaw or Green in Poznań Can't remember what color they were in Kraków/
mafketis   
4 Jun 2019
Travel / Is it safe to drive in Poland? [43]

It is no crime not to cooperate with the police either

It depends on what crime has been committed.... speeding? not sure, hit and run? DUI and hit and run?

they actually enjoy the tyranny

helping to make sure that those who commit infractions have to face the consequences of their actions =/= tyranny
mafketis   
3 Jun 2019
Travel / Is it safe to drive in Poland? [43]

what if the owner of the car doesn't give the details or doesn't know who used his car

somebody's in trouble..... somebody's in trouble....

You become a criminal for a crime you haven't committed

concealing the identity of someone who broke the law is called aiding and abetting, a crime in most places...

Police: Fair enough, good night. We'll contact you about car pickup tomorrow.

Not how US police work. You need to own up to whatever it is you did and pay up. Be a man and not a lawbreaker!
mafketis   
3 Jun 2019
Travel / Is it safe to drive in Poland? [43]

Spain several times over the last 5 years and everyone was so peaceful and quiet

I was in Spain last year and the driving was surprisingly sane. Unlike Malta (love the country but horrible, terrible, awful drivers... did I mention they're terrible?) Once on the way to the airport (after dark) a car with no lights on barreled straight through a traffic circle missing our taxi by less than 5 meters...

As for Poles, they're absolutely abysmal.

not all, I have driven with some very good Polish drivers... they're just not a large majority...
mafketis   
3 Jun 2019
Law / Surname Question - ski/ska [6]

Would I have to take 'ski' or could I choose 'ska'?

In the UK it would probably be better to use 'ski' so that it matches your husband. People in Poland (and the bureaucracy) realize that outside the slavic world women are likely to have names in -ski rather than -ska...

On the other hand it might make it easier to travel with your daughter if the last names match....

Up to you.
mafketis   
3 Jun 2019
Travel / Is it safe to drive in Poland? [43]

Are Polish drivers aggressive and impatient in general?

What struck me in the 1990s was just how stressful driving was physically for the driver.. I remember more than once ending up with a tension headache because the driver just seemed to be a bunch of raw nerves the entire time...

Or course I've been in the car with lots of safe drivers too, but angry, impatient stressed out make up a much higher percentage than in the US... and of course the process for getting a license used to be very corrupt and so there were drivers who'd bought their licenses and barely knew the first thing about road safety...

. Would I be horned at a lot for being too careful?

Maybe more than in the US but nowhere near as much as in Romania (Bucharest is a never ending medley of different car horns).

.Because drivers are prone to doing unpredictable (aka stupid) things

A former colleague from Scotland described their adaptation: I just always expect the worst possible behavior from other drivers... and I'm usually not wrong.
mafketis   
2 Jun 2019
Travel / Is it safe to drive in Poland? [43]

@SafeDriver

Are you in the US? I was trained in the US and have never wanted to drive in Poland because of the very different driving culture. Defensive driving is pretty much a no go. It's all rules and how can you break them and how fast can you go? Then go even faster!

Public transport (occasionally augmented by taxis) are a much better option.
mafketis   
2 Jun 2019
Life / Political correctness in Poland [210]

I voted Konfedracja

i1.kwejk.pl/k/obrazki/2019/05/zNntnT7s7gd2COSX.jpg

Pleae tell me you voted for Bosak, please, please, please tell me you voted for Bosak....

wprost.pl/_thumb/0d/36/4a22bd4280b34e70cc37c9a579d3.jpeg