News /
"Callan Publishing" sues Polish copycats [15]
I found Reward to be a bit lacking but not altogether unusable. Have you taught from Face 2 Face, Jon? It's a Cambridge publication, I think. I'm currently using it with an EMPIK student. I recommend it, the Intermediate version at least :)
Speak Up's (SU) skill is in using the 2 productive and 2 receptive skills. There isn't much use of listening, only the teacher. However, they have different teachers so there's variety.
Callan itself was lucky to get off of home base, having originally being designed to be used by the army to learn German would you believe? Having trained teachers in the method, I can say that you can see the benefits for students in the first four levels but, thereafter, the law of diminishing returns applies. Yes, levels 5 and 6 wheel out a lot of grammar but I far prefer the way I teach it at SU, putting flesh on the bones and allowing students to ask me questions at any time during the lesson. It's not wham bam, thank you mam as Callan tends to be. Teaching needs the personal touch.