History /
Why did Hitler kill so many Jews in Poland? [261]
I don't think you annihilate a whole creed based on being a scapegoat, aphro, it goes well beyond that.
that is not for me to discuss. There are many threads about that already and I agree that the issues of minorities in EU is a complex matter.
Yes but I don't say that I'm from England but am 100% Scottish ;) ;)
who is this question about? You, or me, because you are confusing me now.
Interesting question...
it is.
Is it comparable?
it the way they are shunned? YES.
In the way the are misunderstood? YES.
In the way both groups were "invited" into Europe. I would say YES.
Jews were supporters of communism. So are Muslims today. Generalization, I know, but still ...
so were many non - Jews, so I would disagree. There is a different dynamics at play with Muslims, but for both groups it it is a non win situation. If they assert themselves too much - they are perceived as a group not wanting to assimilate, yet they are given enough freedom to assert themselves - it is a vicious circle really.
I think that Europeans wanted Jews to be the underdog, but who wants to be the underdog for a long time, even the underdog will eventually rebel. Some Jews converted, yet everybody knew there were Jews.
Most Muslims were brought to Europe as guest workers (Germany, Moroco). Nobody wanted them to stay, they were suppose to be the source of cheap labour, yet they, like any other group have needs and want their freedom as well. Europeans want to keep them in the position of underdogs but it is not going to work........
Nonsense. If not for terrorism nobody would give them a second thought.
Terrorism was not a Muslim invention and as far as I know Irish were the leaders in that department due the the ethnic tension in NI/Ireland. One needs to look into the causes of Muslim terrorism and I always look at the terrorism as a sign of desperation.
Some Jews were communists, some were not. Blaming Jews for communism is just another tactics of diverting the attention and an attempt to blame only Jews, while those people who lived in eg communist Poland know very well that a the majority of communist were Polish.