Atch
21 Jun 2017
Work / Dutch translator job Warsaw- salary? [21]
Aniaatje if you read the thread properly you'll see that neither I nor Mafketis thought you were a native English speaker nor that you were offering your services as such but regardless of your English it does seem odd that a company wants to hire you to translate from a language you don't know at all and equally odd that you would be happy to do so. The machine translator will tranlsate French into imperfect Polish which you will then knock into shape, so you're not translating from French but from garbled Polish into correct Polish. I would have serious reservations about such practises.
And what does it tell you about the company that's offering the job? Surely they can find a Polish languages graduate with sufficient knowledge of French to do such a translation so why do they want to hire you? Would you really want to work for a company like that? And believe me, at some point they will ask you to translate into English and you will end up doing so. Now this raises issues of ethics.How would you feel if somebody who didn't know Dutch or Polish was translating from those languages? Doesn't it make a nonsense of your own profession and ultimately undermine you? A translator needs knowledge of both the source and target languages.
Aniaatje if you read the thread properly you'll see that neither I nor Mafketis thought you were a native English speaker nor that you were offering your services as such but regardless of your English it does seem odd that a company wants to hire you to translate from a language you don't know at all and equally odd that you would be happy to do so. The machine translator will tranlsate French into imperfect Polish which you will then knock into shape, so you're not translating from French but from garbled Polish into correct Polish. I would have serious reservations about such practises.
And what does it tell you about the company that's offering the job? Surely they can find a Polish languages graduate with sufficient knowledge of French to do such a translation so why do they want to hire you? Would you really want to work for a company like that? And believe me, at some point they will ask you to translate into English and you will end up doing so. Now this raises issues of ethics.How would you feel if somebody who didn't know Dutch or Polish was translating from those languages? Doesn't it make a nonsense of your own profession and ultimately undermine you? A translator needs knowledge of both the source and target languages.