PolishForums LIVE  /  Archives [3]    
   
Posts by Vlad123  

Joined: 27 Oct 2012 / Male ♂
Last Post: 12 Feb 2013
Threads: Total: 7 / In This Archive: 7
Posts: Total: 204 / In This Archive: 176

Displayed posts: 183 / page 3 of 7
sort: Latest first   Oldest first   |
Vlad123   
13 Jan 2013
Language / Polish/Ukrainian words similarities [209]

It's because the Russian word-stock includes many words of non-Slavic origin like "loshad'" for Slavic words "koń/kin/kun", "glaz" for Slavic "oko" etc.

But do not forget that many Polish words stand for Russian archaic.For example ``oko`` was used in Russian
before ``glaz`` as well as ``Ja wiem``, ``lepo``, ``lepota`` (lepiej), ``chelo``, ``usta`` and many other words.
Vlad123   
6 Jan 2013
History / Ukrainian-occupied Eastern Poland [135]

Have you been proclamed that? I mean how should I refer to you now: as Vlad or use your "proclaimed name"?

My citation was no more than a joke which is based in widely known stereotipes and didn`t contain claims or pretentions to anyone.
Vlad123   
5 Jan 2013
History / Ukrainian-occupied Eastern Poland [135]

Lol, I think they would have quite happily continued on living in Ukrainian Lviv and would have learnt Ukrainian and Russian

Why Russian?As I know you cannot speak Russian in Lviv without threat of being immidiately proclaimed as ``moskal```.
Vlad123   
5 Jan 2013
History / Ukrainian-occupied Eastern Poland [135]

I think this definition is right. According to this definition the SU was not a socialist country as, e.g., millions were staved (Holodomor) to death - and could not "benefit from the country's wealth".

So you believe that Holodomor is direct outcome from fact that Soviet Union was not socialist?But in the last 40 years there was no mass death from starvation.Probably you have to provide more arguments to prove it.

And how social structure of truly socialist country would differ from that of USSR?

Well if some Poles have claim to Lviv and nostalgia,why no to go there and not live there?Sombody prohibits?
Or Ukrainian lang. if way too difficult for Poles?
Vlad123   
3 Jan 2013
History / Ukrainian-occupied Eastern Poland [135]

Vlad, Bandera was Soviet

Honesly I do not care if Bandera was ``pro-Soviet`` in any meaning of this word or not.My question did not contain any word about him.In reality it was:

Do Poles prize ukrainian nationalists for their anti Soviet/Russian views?

I meant that Poles seem to like modern Ukrainian nationalists for their anti-Soviet/Russian rethorics and welcome Ukrainian nationalism as a phenomenon but in the same time themself claim terribly suffered from Ukrainian nationalists.There is some irony in it,is not it?Personally I have nothing against of those Ukrainians who like existnce of their own state or if they are cotious towards Russian government,it is up to them, but at present stage any rhethorics which is able to spark ethnical hate between ethnical Slavs such as Ukrainians and Russians is rather unnecessary in my view.Currently size of Slavic ethnicities is quickly shrinking and ethnical Russians no way threat to Ukraine by demographical expansion.I think there is time to unite for all Slavic nations to compete against old and newly arised powers.In 13-th century Slavic princes already quarrelledwith each other and many died painfully from Mongols.

The name of the country "Union of the Soviet Socialist Republic" is misleading: the country was neither a union (many "republics" were incorporated by force), nor was it soviet (soviet = the power belongs to councils of different levels), nor socialist

Interesting.Could go give your own view on socialism?
Vlad123   
2 Jan 2013
History / Ukrainian-occupied Eastern Poland [135]

Poles came to Ukraine (the principality of Halychyna-Vilhynia in the mid 14th century), stayed there for centuries, built buildings

What remained from their buildings now?

like Bandera, perhaps?

Do Poles prize ukrainian nationalists for their anti Soviet/Russian views?
Vlad123   
2 Jan 2013
News / What should Poland do to solve the population crisis? [101]

You don`t need to have totalitarian system in order to have some kind of artificial reproduction.This is what could be done by private individuals or organisations.For example what prevent some political party in Europe to purchase stem cells from man and woman and hire some surrogate mothers in Third world countries?And after, grow those children in special, highly comfortable boarding schools?At least those children will have some biological parents and could be accepted by them at any time.What is totalitarian here?
Vlad123   
1 Jan 2013
News / What should Poland do to solve the population crisis? [101]

"Growing" European children sounds horrific, as though human beings were a crop. It sounds downright Orwellian.

Probably you mistook Orwell for Aldous Huxley and his ``Brave New World``. But honestly I do not find the world he described a really bad place to live.It may be even better place than our world in some aspects. Though I do not propose to grow people of different quality as he did: such as alphas, betas, epsilones.I`m not against if all new children will be ``alphas`` or at least nobody will grow some mindless biorobots. I think that principally any person or group of people have right to reproduce in any possible way, either natural or artificial.And if they want their children or ``offsprings`` look in some particular way is up to them and nobodies else concern.This is human rights violations in some country that should be concern, not a way of reproduction.

Money stimulos to have children in Eastern European countries most likely will fail as they did in the West.Alcoholics will use most of those funds.
Vlad123   
31 Dec 2012
News / What should Poland do to solve the population crisis? [101]

We need people, educated or uneducated, to have kids. Education is something the State can provide the kids with if they want it.

The more technologically advanced society becomes the more educated people we need.Demand for low skilled positions falls every year or is stagnating.They more likely to become drags for society more and more.

Not all people are capable to get degree or want to do it.Children of drug addicts or alcoholics are less likely to do it.That`s obvious.I do not propose to prohibit them to have children but when it comes to stimulation it is quite different.
Vlad123   
31 Dec 2012
News / What should Poland do to solve the population crisis? [101]

That's extreme and totalitarian.

I didn`t wrote that this is what I personally propose.This is just theoretical assumption.
In which exactly country government support to parents helped increase fertility really much?
Native european population of developed countries principally do not want to reproduce.Economic
methods seem to be almost no use there.And first who will use such social programs will be lowest
shares of society who are not otherwise capable to care about their children and support them.
We need high quality,educated people who will support themself and move countries forward.
Vlad123   
31 Dec 2012
News / What should Poland do to solve the population crisis? [101]

I think that those tendencies could be reversed in foreseable future only if farther things will be invented
or implemented:
1)Scientist will invent method to extend human life and youthfulness drastically.In this case there will be
less need for reproduction.
2)Some kind of artificial reproduction will be implemented.For example surrogate mothers in third world
countries will grow european children.
3)Europeans will be obligated to have at least two children by law.And medical comission will check if
they are fertile or not.
Vlad123   
31 Dec 2012
News / What should Poland do to solve the population crisis? [101]

Polands population is about 38,500,000.
The birth rate in Poland is 1.31.
By 2050 the population will be around 34,000,000

I`m afraid that much less than that if you assume all current tendencies will remain
and there will be no immigration.Birth rate 1.3 means that population should become
smaller almost halved with each new generation.It something close to 50 years timeframe.
If now Polish population is 38,500,000 it means in 2063 it will be approx. 20 mln.
Especially if to count immigration from Poland.
Vlad123   
28 Dec 2012
History / Ukrainian-occupied Eastern Poland [135]

Currently both Ukraine and Poland have territories of sufficient size and no obvious reason for territorial disputes and ultimately have possibility to develop good relations.All those talks about territorial claims is intentional provocation to spark an ethnical conflict.Do you seriously believe that Poland doesn`t have sufficient enough territory now? When whould be the end for those stupid claims: ``We need Ukraine without Ukrainians or with Ukrainians as our slaves``? As population of any Slavic nation is shrinking now,maybe there is time to unite on some new basis?Otherwise both Poland and Ukraine will ultimately loose its Slavic faces and consumed by wisier nations.
Vlad123   
28 Dec 2012
History / Ukrainian-occupied Eastern Poland [135]

There's no need for namecalling. We can all agree that Lvov has a very significant Polish history and has significant cultural importance for Poles in general.

Pardon for my ignorance,but which exacly cultural acheivements happened in Polish Lwow?Which thinkers or scientists originated there?Is it famous for scientific discoveries?
Vlad123   
27 Dec 2012
History / Ukrainian-occupied Eastern Poland [135]

Hypothetically speaking if I would have been in position to claim anything, I would.

You would claim entire Ukraine if you could?! And were would you want to put Ukrainians?
Exterminate or drive them in Siberia?..
Vlad123   
27 Dec 2012
History / Ukrainian-occupied Eastern Poland [135]

As if Rusini have been ever majority there before 1944!

Well,in any case, are you seriously want to claim some city
which whould be surrounded by Ukrainian territory?Or would claim
corridor of land to it?And which parts of Ukraine are you going to
claim beside Lviv?
Vlad123   
27 Dec 2012
History / Ukrainian-occupied Eastern Poland [135]

What a BS! Anyway who cares IT WAS MIDDLE AGED HISTORY!

Since 1772 Lwow was Polish for 19 years only: 1920-1939.
So what was after Middle Ages?

In 1900, when it was still part of the Austrian empire, it's population was 20% Ukrainian, 49% Polish and 27% Jewish.

Not even absolute majority.
Vlad123   
26 Dec 2012
History / Ukrainian-occupied Eastern Poland [135]

1) Lwow had not been founded by Poles.
2) From the end of 18-th century after partition of Poland and till 1918 Lwow beared
the name of Lemberg and was part Austro-Hungarian Empire.Austrian emperor
France Joseph wore Ukrainian national shirt under his cloth according to some sorces
and mastered Ukrainian to the point he was able to write poetry in Ukrainian.Once he
wanted to become a Bukovina king to joy of Ukrainians.Ukrainian soldier liked Austrian
king and called him ``our king``.Return Lwow to Poland and not to Austria?

I`m not going to argue if Lwow was predominantly Polish-speaking or not, though I`m
not sure that ethnical Poles constituted magority of popualation there in the last centuries.
Well,maybe Israel will claim Lwow too?..

Galicia–Volhynia Wars

During the wars over the succession of Galicia-Volhynia Principality in 1339 King Casimir III of Poland undertook an expedition and conquered Lviv in 1340, burning down the old princely castle.[10] Poland ultimately gained control over Lviv and the adjacent region in 1349. From then on the population was subjected to attempts to both Polonize and Catholicize the population.[17]

When in 1387 Władysław retreated from the post of its governor, Galicia-Volhynia became occupied by the Hungarians, but soon Jadwiga, the youngest daughter of Louis, but also ruler of Poland and wife of King of Poland Władysław II Jagiełło, unified it directly with the Crown of the Kingdom of Poland.[10]
Vlad123   
26 Dec 2012
History / Ukrainian-occupied Eastern Poland [135]

But Lwow was was build by Poland,

Lviv was founded on the existent settlement most probably in 1240-1247 by Daniel, ruler of the medieval Ruthenian kingdom of Galicia-Volhynia, and named after his son, Lev.

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lviv

Actually it were Poles who always draw line between themself and ``inferior Ukrainians``. It`s enough to say that until 1939 majority of Ukrainians in Polish governed part of Ukraine didn`t have

any

citizenship! Could you imaging to live on territory where your ancestors lived for a thousand of years maybe, and be treated like underhuman without citizenship? Polish citizenship was granted by special permission of Polish government to minority of Ukrainians only. A way to the higher ranks of Polish society was almost closed to Ukrainians.Well,if some nation permits to itself luxury of meaningless racism and gaining on somebody instead uniting with them against common adversaries, consequences were predictable...
Vlad123   
24 Dec 2012
Travel / Poland in photo riddles [3134]

Why do Poles keep fish in a bath(tub)?

Polish fish producing companies are trying to enter World market?That`s for sure.
I`ve heard about it.
Vlad123   
24 Dec 2012
Language / Polish/Ukrainian words similarities [209]

Yes, that's proving that there are Russian lovers in Poland, nothing else

Do you have some personal problems with Russians? Well, some Russians had
problems with Poles too.According to wikipedia:

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Felix_Dzerzhinsky
Vlad123   
21 Dec 2012
History / What do nations of the world owe to Poland and Polish people? [58]

while the popular beverage was called gorzałka (from the Old Polish gorzeć meaning "to burn"), which is also the source of Ukrainian horilka (горілка).

Rather from Old Slavic.In Russian there is also verb goret` (to burn) - гореть.

Imagine what would have happened if Poland had adopted Orthodox christianity? It is natural we would have formed a lasting alliance with our Eastern neighbours.

They would not even need to adopt Orthodoxy.If Polish nobles would treat Ukrainians/Ruthenians as a humans,Poland most likely would be never partitioned and probably never seriously invaded from the East (at least up to now).

And would be a regional superpower which could rival to both Russia and Germany.
Vlad123   
20 Dec 2012
Language / Polish/Ukrainian words similarities [209]

Principally I think that Ukrainians and Belorussians are probably genetically even closer to
Poles than Russians.Quite possibly researchers mistook Russians for Ukrainians and
Belorussians.Majority of Russians are maybe not that close,especially those who live in
Tatarstan and Karelia.
Vlad123   
20 Dec 2012
Language / Polish/Ukrainian words similarities [209]

Only me?This is citation of your native Polish guy:

Wiedzmin_fan

Edited by: Wiedzmin_fan May 31, 10, 19:27 Reply Quote #

If you run a google search for "genetic map of europe", you'll see some fascinating graphs.

Also, you can look up the following papers:

Nature 456, 98-101 (6 November 2008) | doi:10.1038/nature07331; Received 30 May 2008; Accepted 12 August 2008; Published online 31 August 2008
"Genes mirror geography within Europe"

and
European Journal of Human Genetics (2008) 16, 1413-1429; doi:10.1038/ejhg.2008.210
"Investigation of the fine structure of European populations with applications to disease association studies".

Short answer - yes, it looks like the Poles and the Russians are very close genetically.

https://polishforums.com/genealogy/russian-dna-37610/
This is usually those who spark ethnical hate between nations wash brains to people.I just trying to reduce unnecessary hostility between Slavic nations and make them stand together for freedom and democracy.
Vlad123   
19 Dec 2012
Language / Polish/Ukrainian words similarities [209]

Actually,there is nothing strange in the fact that Polish and Russian languages are so similar.
If you look at this genetic map of Europe it seems that Ameriracan researches believe that
genetics of people in Eastern and Northern Poland is identical to Russians.It is marked RU.

scienceblogs.com/gnxp/2008/08/31/genetic-map-of-europe-genes-va


  • i1d01ee520e5f5c5088.jpg
Vlad123   
19 Dec 2012
Language / Polish/Ukrainian words similarities [209]

Vlad123, do you reside inside or outside of MKAD?

What is MKAD? I thought I live in Northern America...

Your anti-ukrainian attitude is abhorrent. You are a just a Moskal, and please admit it.

What? I`m ethnical Ukrainian and like Ukrainian language.Did I say I do not like it?
But some people should know languages,and if Polish and Russian have many very similar
words that`s a fact and to deny this is laughable...
Ukrainian has its own specifics,it developed not less independently than Russian or Polish
and this is beauty language...