PolishForums LIVE  /  Archives [3]    
   
Posts by hague1cmaeron  

Joined: 30 Mar 2010 / Male ♂
Last Post: 4 Mar 2013
Threads: Total: 14 / In This Archive: 13
Posts: Total: 1366 / In This Archive: 1083
From: Adelaide
Speaks Polish?: yes
Interests: Politics, history, cricket, African mammals etc.

Displayed posts: 1096 / page 24 of 37
sort: Latest first   Oldest first   |
hague1cmaeron   
4 Jan 2011
History / Lwów, Wilno ... kresy - Poland have lost enormoust part of our heritage... [389]

This is my personal opinion - that they massively overestimated just what the Polish Army was capable of. In all fairness, people talk about Russia invading Poland and this is what broke Poland - but Poland was already staring defeat in the face by Germany alone by September 17th.

Yes i would agree with that

Exactly. So, after mobilizing for war they would have had 1.5 million soldiers, so even with
200 thousand of them being Germans and Slovaks, it'd still have been a formidable force.

those are quite useful numbers in terms of a potential ally.
hague1cmaeron   
3 Jan 2011
History / Lwów, Wilno ... kresy - Poland have lost enormoust part of our heritage... [389]

no wonder he try to sell his nation as an ancient entity, rich in culture and history with plenty of great people !
Well, they could stick to the truth - that they are freshmen on the nationhood - that would be good for them !

O come now Ironside, that is just a little bit unfair isn't it? Some of them love to indulge in the culture of other nations. Take for instance this little footage of Ukrainians recently commemorating Stalin with a statue.
hague1cmaeron   
2 Jan 2011
History / Former American President Adams in Poland. [54]

I am afraid that you are wrong, try this for instance:

'Britain did not expect the colonies to contribute to the interest or the retirement of debt incurred during its wars, but they did expect a portion of the expenses for colonial defense to be paid by the Americans.Estimating the expenses of defending the continental colonies and the British West Indies to be approximately £200,000 annually, the British goal after the end of this war was that the colonies would be taxed for £78,000 of this amount. The colonists objected chiefly on the grounds not that the taxes were high (they were low)[20] but that they had no representation in the Parliament. Parliament insisted it had the right to levy any tax without colonial approval, to demonstrate that it had authority over the colonies.'

Seems to me they wanted to have their cake and eat it as well.

What has this got to do with Australian Aboriginals? Besides I live in Australia and the differences between the two are stark.
hague1cmaeron   
2 Jan 2011
History / Former American President Adams in Poland. [54]

They had to tax something, an income tax would have been very unpopular.

as our neighbours took in huge doses of german blood!

That is good, i hear that they are an industrious bunch, although I think i prefer the northern ones to the ones from the south(:

Provided that they come from the north from around Munster and the Danish border, that will be a great addition.
hague1cmaeron   
2 Jan 2011
History / Former American President Adams in Poland. [54]

It wasn't just the taxes. Britain was trying to monopolize markets.

If I remember the taxes were paid by the Americans to pay for their own army to protect them from the French and the Indians, sounds perfectly sensible to me. Instead asking the British taxpayer to help with the upkeep of the British army in America.

And lets not forget about the yanks trying to steal Indian land, as somebody brought to our attention earlier.
hague1cmaeron   
2 Jan 2011
UK, Ireland / Do Poles in the UK pretend to be uppity because they have an inferiority complex? [60]

Usually very competitive people who want to impress other people are like this, because they feel they have to be on top of everyone else. They may even appear weak and shy, but deep down inside they want to have all the power. I admit, I suffer from this and it is truly a disease, but it is pretty easy for me to pick out someone with an inferiority complex because of it.

That is an interesting observation, but than again doesn't everyone suffer from the same deficiency at some point in time? A lot of it comes down to mood, we all have times when we feel on top of the world and times when we feel as though we cannot sink any lower. It is a bit like the weather.
hague1cmaeron   
28 Dec 2010
History / Former American President Adams in Poland. [54]

Not being far from the borders of Poland, he criticizes the fact that "numerous (Prussian) officers have been placed there, who treat the Poles too much as a conquered people," rather than as citizens of Prussia.

No surprise there than(:
hague1cmaeron   
28 Dec 2010
News / Polish twins have different fathers [67]

In South africa they call this a "Fok-Op" wonder why xD

So you have some sort of SAFA connection is that right?
hague1cmaeron   
17 Dec 2010
News / US Military: The Army of Poland is crap. [124]

Brigadier General Andrzej Reudowicz

You have got to be kidding me, if he doesn't come from taxes and uses a lavatory instead of choking his chicken (Schwarzkopf) than he must be useless.
hague1cmaeron   
17 Dec 2010
News / US Military: The Army of Poland is crap. [124]

Oh, so now it's the turn of the Poles to be complained about (the germans and the brits have previously been on the receiving end). maybe everyone should just pull out and leave the US to it, as they seem to be the only ones who know how to do it properly...

My thoughts exactly, we all know that the yanks are really bad ass mother......

So yes leave them to it. obviously the whole world is incompetent and incapable, completely useless when it comes to torturing others and rubbing people's noses in it, instead of knocking people's doors down they actually knock on the door..... useless.
hague1cmaeron   
11 Dec 2010
Work / Polish students among best in OECD [32]

and what are your conclussions?

They are mostly problem based. These tests have been only in operation in Poland for about 10 years, and the biggest adjustment has been undertaken by the teachers. They have to adopt their method of teaching in order to enable the students to learn how to approach these tests. Each country's representative has a bit of a say in how the tests are conducted. Overall I would be inclined to say that they are quite reflective of reality.
hague1cmaeron   
9 Dec 2010
Work / Polish students among best in OECD [32]

Actually zetigrek it wouldn't suprise me much if Polish students move up in those test.

No actually class size has very little bearing on good performance, teacher quality is infinitely more important.

Because - I think the tests are measuring pure knowledge. They're not measuring things like problem solving - so Poland ends up artifically high because the education system here is very good at teaching "facts".

Actually it is the other way around. The tests are mostly concerned with problem solving skills. In case you ask, I know all this because I have been recently doing some education research for my boss-and methodology research not that fun):
hague1cmaeron   
9 Dec 2010
News / Poles don't have a heart for math... says The New York Times [84]

Seriously, how can people complain about this article? It seems to be rather factual - unless of course, the usual revisionists wish to deny that Mathematics wasn't a compulsory part of the Matura for the last 9 years.

ummmm acording to PISA (2009) Poland is ranked 24th in Maths, that is in comparison to 26th for the UK, so I am guessing that Maths is not as big a problem as it is made out to be. Having said that, I do believe that it is very important and should undoubtedly get greater billing, and I am sure they can improve on 24th, they are ranked 9th in literacy for instance.

Labour has been a disaster when it comes to British education, all those billions wasted. Proof if ever there was any, that spending more money on education does not automatically bring results.

You are right though, mathematics should definitely be compulsory during Matura, and the fact that it wasn't probably impoverished Poland's performance in this subject. I would go further and say that doing maths during Mature should count for extra points, that is they way it works here in Auss.
hague1cmaeron   
8 Dec 2010
UK, Ireland / Why British men move to Poland [63]

Fatness does not = ugliness...

You are right does not. Though it can but a future strain on the budget(:
hague1cmaeron   
8 Dec 2010
UK, Ireland / Why British men move to Poland [63]

Harsh but... I wonder if there is an opposite trend for Polish females regarding Polish males(:
hague1cmaeron   
6 Dec 2010
History / The Greatest King of Poland? [117]

BTW, how many orthodox or protestant believers live now in Poland? May be they need support? May be it is right time to rise the dissident movement again?

Yes, and turn a blind eye to Russia's oppression of its own religious minorities as in the past....Humbug

Hypocrisy should be written into the Russian constitution, as the founding principle of the Russian nation.
hague1cmaeron   
4 Dec 2010
News / Poland has low murder rate [60]

Shouldn't something be done? Lowest in the EU!

I know that is disgusting
hague1cmaeron   
3 Dec 2010
News / Polish 83 years old lady, who killed her neighbour in Austria, captured. [7]

The neigbour was actually asked before she was told the she was a killer by the reporter 'so what did you think of her, was she maybe nice or...' the reply ' No actually she was rather quarrelsome.." reporter: "did you know that she actually murdered someone?"
hague1cmaeron   
3 Dec 2010
News / Poland has low murder rate [60]

Interesting to note, Poland excludes "assault leading to death" in homicide statistics

Yes the method of measuring crime is very important, as well as reporting etc.

Interesting stats though
hague1cmaeron   
30 Nov 2010
History / Christopher Colombowicz: America's discoverer Polish not Portuguese, claim historians [60]

Now let someone tell me that there is no antipolish sentiment...

You are not wrong about that, try some of these little gems.

this one is from a doctor: "I notice you picked a particularly Polish looking (ie. round and greasy) picture of CC for this post." (-my response to him would be you are from America buddy, last time I had a look there were quite a few round greasy individuals in your country)

"you should've seen him try to tie his shoe."

"Which explains all the sailors lost while digging graves for funerals at sea."

"Hah!! That explains it all. Speaking of which, anybody know why all the polish navy's submarines have glass bottoms? So they can see their air force. Sorry, couldn't resist."

and this an extract from the actual article: 'New research indicates that Christopher Columbus was the son of a Polish king! "How many explorers does it take to mistake the Bahamas for China?"

New research indicates that Christopher Columbus was the son of a Polish king! "How many explorers does it take to mistake the Bahamas for China?" would be an inappropriate response. Give up some respect. Who's your daddy now, America? (Poland.)

gawker.com/5701340/christopher-columbus-was-polish

Yes being a Pole can be a bit tough sometimes):
hague1cmaeron   
28 Nov 2010
History / Poland, Lacking External Enemies, Turns on Itself [106]

Well, like with most papers hyperbole always takes center stage. Most people in Poland choose not to define themselves by politicians, and go about their lives as usual. ********* happens as far as most of them are concerned.
hague1cmaeron   
20 Nov 2010
News / Local elections in Poland, EU citizens should register to vote [57]

PO: we don't do anything that promise
PiS: we say we do everything that we promise, but don't actually do anything we promise

Well that is the slanted point of view of the media. The truth is somewhere in between-if you want to track the activity of PO, then I would suggest you look at the Sejm website and look at all the laws that were approved.

And although I like the strong presence of independents in the election, the fact is that most of the big fish in Katowice, Poznan, Krakow, and Wroclaw-will still be largely dependent on the goodwill of the councilors and Sejmiks, which will be mostly party controlled, to get anything done.

So if an independent tells you that he is going to o this that and etc- you should be very skeptical, because the likelihood is that he or she is simply unlikely to have the power. Therefore a party affiliated promise is far more credible.

If the PO Carries out its policy and reduces the size of parliament (they will have to have the power first) then they will well and truly win my respect as a party that is not just in it for itself. The Conservatives are on their way of doing just that in the UK-and guess which party stands in opposition? Who else but the party of professional politicians- LABOUR.
hague1cmaeron   
20 Nov 2010
History / The Greatest King of Poland? [117]

Prussians did not fight, their only attempt at besieging Warsaw turned into humiliation, the war with Russia was an effective stalemate, Poland was not losing.

You are wrong on both counts, and I am afraid that you are letting nationalist sentiment cloud you judgment.
1. It wasn't a stalemate- if it was, why did the Polish forces continually withdraw and mostly fight a rearguard action? The Russians had Warsaw in their sights, and they would have pounded it into rubble and murdered all and sundry if the king did not capitulate and surrender.

2. Though glorious in the popular imagination, Racwawice is hardly a great victory and a minor battle in the greater scheme of things. Even if for one second i were to concede and say that it was a stalemate (which it wasn't) The important thing is that the battle was fought on Polish soil-not Russian, and it was the Poles who suffered the most.

3. If the Poles would have shown any possible sign of success (which they did not) Than the Prussians would have put greater forces into the field.

4. Although the Poles had the numbers they did not have the equipment to fight a sustained battle against two professional armies.

And finally not all Poles were in favor of the revolution, many landlords actively supported the Russian forces.

So to bring things full circle-the king had no choice but to surrender.

And I am not depreciating the revolution, it was quite extraordinary by European standards. I am just looking at the matter realistically.

that is then and not than.

Anyhow further more to my earlier point they fought and lost battles(in which they were greatly outnumbered) like the Battle of Szczekociny-against the combined armies of Russia and Prussia.

They also lost the battle of Battle of Chełm.

Trust me Polish history is grand enough for you not to have to embellish it any further.