PolishForums LIVE  /  Archives [3]    
   
Posts by DominicB  

Joined: 28 Sep 2012 / Male ♂
Warnings: 1 - O
Last Post: 23 Sep 2020
Threads: -
Posts: Total: 2706 / In This Archive: 2159
From: Chicago
Speaks Polish?: Yes

Displayed posts: 2159 / page 22 of 72
sort: Latest first   Oldest first
DominicB   
26 Jun 2017
Work / Career in Poland - working in finance / investment banking / venture capital / private equity [19]

@polska1234

If you're a teenager, then don't study generic finance, but rather a major that is heavy in applied math, like financial engineering, financial mathematics, econometrics or actuarial science. Math-intensive degrees will greatly increase your chances of finding a great job, and also substantially increase your lifetime earning potential. You'll also have a lot less competition. Study at a top-notch university like Imperial College or London School of Economics.
DominicB   
21 Jun 2017
Life / Long-term living and working in Poland [12]

The reason I ask is because if I think long term, at some point I'd have to think about being able to provide for a family.

That's why Poland is not an attractive location for Americans to work in. Wages are low, the cost of living is rather high relative to wages, and that makes saving money extremely difficult. Your savings potential in the US will be several times higher than it would be in Poland.

8000 PLN gross is about $24,000 bucks a year. That's less than burger flippers make in some states in the US.

That's about 5000 PLN net a month. 2000 to 2500 PLN for housing, all inclusive including rent, administration fees and all utilities except internet/telephone/TV.

Food and sundry household expenses will set you back between 1000 to 2000 PLN a month: more if you eat or snack out a lot, and less if you cook all meals at home from the simplest and cheapest Polish ingredients.

One thing that everyone forgets is to deduct the cost of relocating to and from Poland from the wages you earn there. That includes airfare and all other traveling expenses, shipping, visas and residency permits.

Then there is clothing and other occasional purchases. And entertainment, recreation and travel.

Your going to have trouble saving anything more than a very modest rainy day fund. Serious saving is out of the question.

10k gross or net? If it's net we're talking about a salary in the 98th percentile.

That is completely irrelevant to you. You are not in that demographic sample, never will be, and have zero in common with it.
DominicB   
15 Jun 2017
Study / Wroclaw Economic University, Lodz University or Katowice Economic university? [10]

if i do not meet the criteria required for studying this course, can they confirm my application?

No.You will not be accepted into the course if you do not fulfill the prerequisite requirements. This is a serious course, and competition for places will be stiff.

As far as i know Poland legislation gives permission to foreign students to work.

Having permission to work and actually finding a job are two different things. I highly doubt that anyone would hire you in Poland. And I suspect once you figure that out, you will leave Poland to work illegally in a richer country in the EU.

When you meet the Polish consul. he will have already made a decision: that you are an economic refugee that has no intention to ever leave the EU and return to your own country. Why else would a poor student from a developing country who knows absolutely nothing about Poland apply for studies here? The burden will be 100% on you to convince him that he is wrong. Based on your posts on this forum, that is going to be near impossible. You've already admitted that your primary reason for studying in Poland is not to study, but to avoid military service in your own country. And that is a very good reason for you never to return to your own country.

I'm trying to help you and save you money and time rather than waste it on a ill-conceived attempt at entering the EU and staying illegally. What would be the consequences if you got deported back to your country? Can you be sent to jail for illegally evading military service?

I don't think you have thought this out at all.

Again. my advice is to fulfill your military obligations and think about studying afterward.
DominicB   
15 Jun 2017
Study / Wroclaw Economic University, Lodz University or Katowice Economic university? [10]

Yes, that's a serious course, but the prerequisites might be beyond what you have behind your belt. Looking at the course description and syllabus, it looks like you will already have to have a pretty solid math background, including calculus, multivariate calculus, differential equations, linear algebra, formal logic and some pretty serious statistics and probability courses to handle the curriculum and be accepted into the program, and rather decent programming skills and research skills, as well. If you have a very strong math background, then this is a good course for you. If you don't have a strong math background, you will be totally lost on day one and never be able to catch up, and you will not be able to finish the course, or even the first semester.

Yes i would like to find employment and stay in Poland or another richer country in EU

Make your plans on the very safe assumption that you will never be able to earn even a single penny during your stay in Poland. It's very clear that you are making you plans on the assumption that you are going to be able to earn money during your stay in the EU. Disabuse yourself of that assumption, or you will fail miserably.
DominicB   
15 Jun 2017
Law / Poland tourist visa refusal [10]

im wondering how to proof that i wana return to my country, that i don't have any intentions to stay in Poland

Pretty much impossible for a penniless student. Frankly, you have no credible reason to return to Morocco. You can't show proof of something that you don't have. No amount of documents is going to change that, and your plan of transferring money to your bank account is just plain silly.
DominicB   
15 Jun 2017
Study / Wroclaw Economic University, Lodz University or Katowice Economic university? [10]

@Teymurzade

I suspected that there was more to your motives than serious study.

First of all, as an investment, studying in the programs you listed in Poland will return nothing in terms of future employment or academic opportunities. So if you are satisfied with paying that money for the sole purpose of avoiding the army, and nothing else, then go for it. Those universities might be good universities for students studying in Polish, but not for those studying in English. Courses taught at Polish universities in the English language are a joke, and every employer worth working for in the business and finance world knows that.

If you need to find work in Poland to finance your plan, then forget about it. You are not going to find work, and when you run out of money, you will have no choice but to return to your home country and go to the army. Might as well go to the army now and keep the money in your bank account for more realistic studies at a future date.

I suspect that you do not have adequate funds saved up to finance your studies and your stay in Poland, and that you are counting on finding employment there, or of absconding to work illegally in a richer country in the EU with no intention of ever returning to your home country.

I think that, if you were to apply for a visa, the consul would have little difficulty coming to the same conclusion, and would deny your application.

That will come back to haunt you in the future, as you will probably never be able to get visa to any EU country for the rest of your life. The Polish consul is required to enter his refusal into a data bank that is available to all other EU countries, and once you are on that list, all subsequent applications from all other EU countries will be summarily denied.

Actually, going to the army now and getting it over with seems like the best course of action available to you in the long term. I think your plan of "studying" in Poland will turn out to be a huge waste of time and money, and you will end up in the army back in your own country anyway, just poorer. That is, if you manage to get a visa at all, which I doubt.
DominicB   
14 Jun 2017
Love / DO RELIGIOUS POLISH GIRLS STILL EXIST IN THIS GENERATION [66]

A BBBIIIIIIGGGG thing in Poland right now is Fr John Baptist Bashobora, a Ugandan Charismatic priest who has been putting on huge "Jesus in a Stadium" shows and claims not only to be a faith healer, but also to have resurrected dozens of people from the dead. He is a perfect example of the Pentacostal ideal of preacher as showman.

I'm as surprised as you that he was able to find such a large following among Polish Catholics, who I always thought of as a bit frumpy in terms of worship style.
DominicB   
14 Jun 2017
Love / DO RELIGIOUS POLISH GIRLS STILL EXIST IN THIS GENERATION [66]

@gumishu

I don't get where you are coming from. In a Pentacostal setting, faith healing is very much a spectacle and a performance. A form of stage magic.

@delphiandomine

There are quite a few of them, and they are quite visible. Don't know about Poland, but you'll find plenty of them in the States. Quite popular among Latin Americans, Koreans and Filipinos.
DominicB   
14 Jun 2017
Love / DO RELIGIOUS POLISH GIRLS STILL EXIST IN THIS GENERATION [66]

@gumishu

One of the most striking features of Pentacostalism/Charismaticism is their history of conducting religious services as a form of mass entertainment. Very different from other Protestant and Catholic groups. Their churches are essentially theaters, and their services are essentially stage performances. In fact, their early churches were often converted theater spaces.

Nothing disparaging meant by that. That's just their style of worship.
DominicB   
14 Jun 2017
Genealogy / Is Tuga (Female) / Tugi (Male) a Polish surname? [12]

@gumishu

Serbo-Croatian has been separate from Polish and Ukrainian for 1400 years now, so there is certainly no connection there except possibly a cognate derived from common slavic. Stankiewicz says that the source is Old East Slavic.
DominicB   
14 Jun 2017
Genealogy / Is Tuga (Female) / Tugi (Male) a Polish surname? [12]

@gumishu

It does not mean "big" or "fat" or anything like that, and it is clearly polonified. The Ukrainian original would be transliterated "Tuchyj" in Polish.

If you disagree, take it up with Stankiewicz:

stankiewicze.com/index.php?kat=44&sub=777
DominicB   
14 Jun 2017
Genealogy / Is Tuga (Female) / Tugi (Male) a Polish surname? [12]

@JTugi

Yes, It is a polonified form of an originally Ukrainian surname, which makes sense given the fact that your ancestors came from Wołyń.

It is derived from an old Ukrainian word for "worry". It has nothing to do with "tęgi", though.
DominicB   
14 Jun 2017
Study / Wroclaw Economic University, Lodz University or Katowice Economic university? [10]

@Teymurzade

English-language courses at any of them aren't going to help you find a good job anywhere. They would be a complete waste of time and money. I think I recommended studying financial engineering to you before. And do it either at the University of Warsaw or SGH. That is probably the only way you are going to break into this rather exclusive field.
DominicB   
14 Jun 2017
Travel / Information on Gliwice needed [41]

@venavinis

That would be asking too much. You would have to go to Kraków or Wrocław to find anything like that, and even then, you're going to find a limited selection. Perhaps there is something in Katowice, as well. There are a few online vendors who ship items like that. Search for them.
DominicB   
14 Jun 2017
Work / What is deducted from a salary in Poland apart from Income tax? [155]

@Doodler

The thing that I would be scared of the most is employer-provided accommodation. God only knows what that entails. It could be a nice apartment, or it could be totally not to your satisfaction. Who knows? If you and your wife decide that you would rather live elsewhere, you will not be able to because you cannot afford it.

As to having to buy utensils and bedclothes, you probably will. Sometimes these things come included, but usually don't.

Yes, the cost of living for you and your family will be quite a bit higher for you as foreigners in Poland than as Indians in India. There is no way that you will be able to live as cheaply as the locals because you do not know the language and do not have a network of family and friends to help you.

Even with the travel reimbursement taken into account, it is going to be hard for you to live and save at the same level you now do so in India. Forget about Poland and focus on finding work in richer countries where savings potential is much higher. Don't rely on the internet or "recruiters". "agents" or "consultants". Expand and exploit your network of real-world contacts in your field, especially those who work or have worked in richer countries. The best jobs are advertised solely by word of mouth, face to face in the real world. Internet job sites and "recruiters" get the table scraps, the low-paid, lousy jobs that no one in the know wants.
DominicB   
14 Jun 2017
Work / What is deducted from a salary in Poland apart from Income tax? [155]

Also remember this - once you have committed yourself to being in Poland, you may find that you want to leave within the first month.....

If you are able to save 800 USD a month now in India, and saving money is a prime concern for you, and not just surviving until you find work in the UK, there is little point in coming to Poland in the first place for the wages offered. It would take a huge raise to justify the move. The formula I use for a mid-career foreign worker is at least 5000 PLN a month for a single male, 2500 PLN for a wife, and 1500 PLN per child PLUS cost of school/daycare, which can be up to 4000 PLN a month per child in a good school, PLUS the amount you want to save or send back home per month. 800 USD is about 3000 PLN, so you can see that you will not be able to save anywhere near 800 USD on the amount of money you will be earning. You might not be able to save anything at all. And you will not be able to afford accommodation anywhere if you are not satisfied with the accommodation your employer provides.
DominicB   
14 Jun 2017
Work / What is deducted from a salary in Poland apart from Income tax? [155]

@Doodler

First of all, you have to take your total travel and relocation expenses for you and your family to and from Poland, divide it by 12, and deduct that from your monthly income. This includes airfare, travel expenses to and from airports, including hotel stays if applicable, visas and residency permits. This money has to come from somewhere and that somewhere is your first years income in Poland. For three people, that will be around 1000 PLN a month, perhaps a little more.

Food and sundry regular household expenses for a foreign family of three: 1500 to 2500 PLN a month. More if you eat, drink or snack away from home a lot. Less if you make all your food at home from cheap, local ingredients that the locals eat: pork, chicken, bland fish (pollock and Vietnamese catfish) potatoes, cabbage, onions, carrots, macaroni, and bread. Beef and better fish are expensive, and lamb and seafood are expensive and difficult to find. Quality and selection of fruits and vegetables is very poor compared to India, and they are quite expensive out of season. You'll be able to find spices and a few Indian items in the largest cites or online, but many of the things you take for granted cannot be bought here.

Clothing in Poland is expensive, and you will have to buy winter clothing. Children's clothing and any items for children are very expensive. Daycare for the child can cost 500 PLN a month or more. A good English medium school is extremely expensive and you will not be able to afford that. You will have to send your child to a low quality English medium school or to Polish school. Yes, they do not speak English in Polish schools and your child will receive very little help unless he learns Polish well.

Your wife will not be able to find any work in Poland. At all. Not even cleaning toilets. There are very few Indian women in Poland, a couple hundred in the whole country of 38 million, so she will have extreme difficulty meeting other Indian women of the right caste/clan/class to socialize with. And unless she speaks Polish, she's going to have a hard time meeting Polish people to socialize with. There is no Indian community in Poland, even in the capital city. Most of the few Indians here are single young men who stay for a year or two and move on. The rest are predominantly male students.

You are going to have to spend money, and quite a bit of it, to keep your wife entertained and occupied. Otherwise she is going to go stir-crazy and want to go back for costly visits to India, which you cannot afford on what you are making. Winter is probably going to depress the hell out of her. It's not at all like London where there are a lot of things for an educated Indian woman to do. Without knowing Polish, she will be handicapped in her choice of activities. Even shopping will be difficult, and more expensive.

It will take you and your wife several years to learn even the basics of Polish. It's a complicated language that is not at all similar to English.

As for savings, you're definitely not going to be able to save 50 K a month like you are now. You'd have to be very frugal and lucky to save 20 K, and probably a lot less, or even nothing at all.

All of this is assuming that your employer is paying 100% of the cost of your housing for the duration of your stay. That includes rent, administration fees, and all utilities. If you have to pay any of these costs, then your expenses per month will exceed your income. And woe unto you should you not be happy with the accommodation the employer provides. You would have no choice by to get on the plane back to India.

Bottom line, if you are able to save 50 K in India, then you are now way better off than if you would take this job in Poland.
DominicB   
12 Jun 2017
Life / Settle in Poland, which city is best? [30]

@globetrekker

If you're an EU citizen, and free to come and go, then spend a couple of months in Lublin and/or Białystok before you commit.
DominicB   
12 Jun 2017
Life / Settle in Poland, which city is best? [30]

Narva in Estonia

Precisely the city I was thinking of. It's right on the Russian border, and only 70 km from St. Petersburg.
DominicB   
12 Jun 2017
Life / Settle in Poland, which city is best? [30]

@globetrekker

Why, then, Poland, and not Lithuania, Latvia or Estonia, countries that have sizable Russian minorities and border directly on Russia? If you're looking for a "Russian-like" lifestyle, I'm a bit confused why you think you would find it in Poland. Polish lifestyle is very different from Russia. The three countries I mentioned were all once part of the USSR. Poland never was. It's true that northeastern Poland was once part of the Russian Empire, but that was a hundred years ago. Poland did not absorb too much Russian cultural influence at that time, and what little it did absorb then and during communist times has largely disappeared. Even in Białystok, I saw the "Eastern European" practically disappear during my stay in Poland. There was a distinct "Eastern" feel when I first visited there in 2002, but that was all but gone when I last visited three years ago. Lublin has never felt "Eastern European" to me. It's solidly Polish, and Western.
DominicB   
12 Jun 2017
Life / Settle in Poland, which city is best? [30]

I also specifically like Ukraine and Russia, but right now I don't have residency of either of them and have no way to settle there, so Poland is as close I can to have similar feeling within EU.

I remember your posts from several months ago, and I told you then that Poland, even eastern Poland, is very different from Russia. Russian influence has been decreasing rapidly for almost thirty years now, and has all but disappeared. There is no sizable concentrated minority of Russians living in Poland, but there are in the Baltic countries: Lithuania, Latvia and Estonia, all of which border on Russia. You will find it a lot easier to learn Russian in these countries as it is one of the languages you will hear on the street everyday.

Also, Poland does not have retirement visas. You'll have to check whether the other countries I mentioned do.

Can you refresh my memory of why you are unable to settle in Russia, and why you think staying in the EU would be easier? I would have thought it would be the other way around?
DominicB   
12 Jun 2017
Real Estate / Cost of rent for a four room apartment outskirt of Wroclaw [17]

@mokasha

All inclusive, rent, administration fees and all utilities except internet/TV/telephone will be anywhere from 1500 to 2000 PLN. The cheaper studio apartments have one big defect that can end up costing you money: they often have kitchens that are far too small to be of any practical use, so you end up eating out a lot, which is very expensive in Poland. Better to pay more for an apartment with a good, workable kitchen. Also, studio apartments in Poland are very much sought after, and therefore the price is often only a little less than a one-bedroom apartment.

Like Atch said above, the advertised prices usually do not include administration fees and utilities, so don't forget to find out what they are and include them in your calculations.
DominicB   
11 Jun 2017
Love / DO RELIGIOUS POLISH GIRLS STILL EXIST IN THIS GENERATION [66]

@WielkiPolak

There is a HUGE difference in level of religiosity and religious practice between young Poles and their parents and grandparents, and this is also reflected in politics, as well. The average PIS voter is substantially older than the average PO voter.
DominicB   
11 Jun 2017
Language / How many words does it take to be fluent in (the Polish) language? [21]

Wouldn't that be somwhat comparable to Enlgish?

It's a lot more extreme than English. It's as if the word now pronounced "night" was spelled and pronounced as if were once pronounced "medclosub". English has at least a vaguely recognizable orthography. Tibetan is pronounced extremely different from how it is written, and there are few clues in the written language which could guide you as far as pronunciation is concerned.