PolishForums LIVE  /  Archives [3]    
   
Posts by hague1cmaeron  

Joined: 30 Mar 2010 / Male ♂
Last Post: 4 Mar 2013
Threads: Total: 14 / In This Archive: 13
Posts: Total: 1366 / In This Archive: 1083
From: Adelaide
Speaks Polish?: yes
Interests: Politics, history, cricket, African mammals etc.

Displayed posts: 1096 / page 22 of 37
sort: Latest first   Oldest first   |
hague1cmaeron   
30 Jan 2011
News / Poland goes bankrupt? [110]

there's a huge black hole, and the only way to stop it is to put a stop to all those generous early retirement provisions.

You are right that is going to come into force in the following months, especially targeting the police and the armed forces. And the great thing is from PO's perspective that they cannot strike(:

But seriously though looking into the future the situation looks really bright with PO likely to win a second term, and again drawing on the UK comparison-since that is the one I know best. The Conservatives in the UK will face an uphill battle to win the next election (it pains me to say), because they are prepared to undertake some of the cuts. Labour by contrast believes there is no need for these cuts, but can you believe what would happen if they had their way and th UK suddenly reversed its policy, the financial markets would start to panic!

Another problem is the fact the the UK recovery seems to very anemic, by contrast Poland is likely to grow by some 4.8%-5.2% this year, that is not bad at all as is likely to take some pressure of the government.
hague1cmaeron   
30 Jan 2011
News / Poland goes bankrupt? [110]

Please stop polluting this thread with your rubbish.
hague1cmaeron   
30 Jan 2011
News / Poland goes bankrupt? [110]

And this is the real problem - the majority of Poles are fundamentally socialist.

You really should look at the figures instead of buying into propaganda. which one of these is socialist?

UK:
Basic tax rate 20%
Higher rate 40%
top rate 50%
Main rate for corporation tax 27%
VAT rate 20%
Sovereign states by public debt rating 21
Insurance rate 12. 8%
rate of gov spending 47.3 percent of GDP
Overall tax revenue 38.9% of GDP

Poland:
basic rate 18%
top rate 32%
corporate tax 19%
VAT rate 23% standard rate and 5%/8% on food
Sovereign states by public debt 50
Insurance rate 13.71%
Rate of gov spending 43.3% percent of GDP
Overall tax revenue 34.9 % of GDP

Based on the above stats, I would note that Poland has a smaller public sector than the UK+taking into account that Poland still possess public assets that it can sell and is selling worth billions of dollars, and the UK does not Poland is in an infinitely better position.

As to the political appetite for reform, in Poland the government is currently undertaking pensions reform, in the UK the government wouldn't dare to mention the subject.

Socialists, which socialists?

Seems to me it is the UK that is in much need of a double dose of Thacherism, but given the strong class hatred prevalent in UK society, it is going to be very hard to achieve.
hague1cmaeron   
30 Jan 2011
News / Poland goes bankrupt? [110]

Poland's GDP is on the rise for a very simpe reason.Poland is the only country in EU to have a mobile workforce.So when the economy is on the rise in UK they move to UK when it regresses in UK they go to Sweden and when Sweden slows down they go to Germany.In this way they avoid the regional break ups and declines.

My goodness you are thicko, aren't you?

My employer would disagree.

I am guessing that your employment has nothing to do with economics.

Here, just for you and others who keep on spouting all this BS: warsawvoice.pl/WVpage/pages/articleFilm.php?id=14
hague1cmaeron   
29 Jan 2011
News / Poland goes bankrupt? [110]

Media finally start admitting the obvious
3 years of coward Tusk and less than a year of that village idiot "president" was enough...

You are so economically illiterate, that it is not even funny.
hague1cmaeron   
28 Jan 2011
History / Poland obliged to make war reparations to Austria and Germany after WWI. Why? [119]

Come now BB, we must pay attention. The scorched earth, is a Russian tactic, Germans did not do that in WWI. You seem to be far to harsh on th Germans BB(:

Yes the reparations are the main bit that interests me. But Zamoyski did mention the confiscation of property and so does the the little snippet that I have pasted. Alas I am still going to have to write to the publisher to find out.

The practices mentioned by Zamoyski seem to be overwhelmingly indulged in by the Russians from the information I have come across.
hague1cmaeron   
28 Jan 2011
History / Poland obliged to make war reparations to Austria and Germany after WWI. Why? [119]

Whilst this is not the year Zamoyski is talking about, this is an example of the stuff he Is talking about:

The destruction and sacking of the city of Kalisz (Polish: zburzenie Kalisza) occurred in August 1914 by German Empire troops. From August 2 until 22 1914, at the beginning of World War I, one of the oldest towns in Poland (then under Partitions), with a rich historical tradition, and monuments of mediaeval architecture was bombed and burnt down. It was committed on a defenceless, open town, which the Russian army had left without fighting. The event is also known as Pogrom of Kalisz or Poland's Louvain.

As depicted in film(must say the troops do look smart in their uniform)
hague1cmaeron   
27 Jan 2011
Life / Are Poles bankrupt? [35]

The real question is not if they are, but how much they are in debt?

Jane, give it a rest honey, your knowledge of economics is clearly as about as substantial as a hermit's address book.
hague1cmaeron   
26 Jan 2011
Polonia / Life in Poland vs Norway - good for children, benefits, etc? [43]

I live in Poland now, and I'm respecting their way of doing things, and they respect mine.

Don't worry and don't feel offended about about the observations on this forum, if you stay here long enough you will realize that most people just say whatever pops into their heads. Some of them actually set deliberately to provoke to create an argument. I am glad you chose to make Poland your home and feel free to share your observations however frank they may be.
hague1cmaeron   
26 Jan 2011
History / Poland obliged to make war reparations to Austria and Germany after WWI. Why? [119]

That is a good idea I think I might do that, yes I kind of thought about doing that, now I think I will(:

After further investigation I guess that might not be an option , it seems that the email is that of his publisher):

I guess I just have to do some further research.

found something:

Upon Ober Ost's inception in 1915, Erich Ludendorff, von Hindenburg's second in command set up a system of managing the large area under Ober Ost's jurisdiction. Although von Hindenburg was technically in command, it was Ludendorff who was in control of the administration. There were ten staff members, each with a speciality (finance, agriculture, etc.). The area was divided into the Courland District, the Lithuania District and the Bialystok-Grodno District, each overseen by a district commander. Ludendorff's plan was to make Ober Ost a colonial territory for the settlement of his troops after the war [...]

This is prior to 1918 though, so still got to keep at it.
hague1cmaeron   
25 Jan 2011
Life / Are Poles bankrupt? [35]

Though the UK (though not Scotland's)

You have got to be kidding right?
hague1cmaeron   
25 Jan 2011
History / Poland obliged to make war reparations to Austria and Germany after WWI. Why? [119]

Well...then better talk about Russians and not Germans in WWI. I'm not an expert on russian history.

PS: In 1915 there hadn't been "polish territories".

Yes I am looking for the German involvement as mentioned by Zamoyski, but in the meantime more on the Russian contribution:

According to Edward Werner:

Millions of tourists visited the battlefields of France after the First World War, but only a few pushed further and investigated the devastation caused by the World War in Poland. A few figures might serve to illustrate this destruction: About 2,000,000 houses were damaged and had to be rebuilt, actual battlefields extended over one-fourth of the surface of the country. Direct war damages were computed at $2,500,000,000. Three billion feet of earth alone had to be shifted to fill excavated trenches. The loss of human life, which I should have mentioned first, is hard to estimate for Poles fought in all three contending armies. A part of Poland then belonging to Russia was deliberately laid waste in order to deprive the Germans of the necessary supplies. The inhabitants of that region were evacuated to Russia. When famine occurred in Russia in 1923 after the Bolshevik Revolution, these people were sent back by the Russians under the most appalling conditions.

He is quite specific about the title of this operation, where did he get his info from, I wander.
hague1cmaeron   
25 Jan 2011
History / Poland obliged to make war reparations to Austria and Germany after WWI. Why? [119]

That only happened once, during "Total war" in WWII.

I am not mixing up wars:

"In 1915 Polish territories were looted and abandoned by the retreating Russian army, trying to emulate the scorched earth policy of 1812;[1][2] the Russians also evicted and deported hundreds of thousands of its inhabitants suspected of collaborating with the enemy.[1][3][4] By the end of 1915, the Germans had occupied the entire Russian sector, including Warsaw. In 1916 another Russian offensive in Galicia exacerbated the already desperate situation of civilians in the war zone; about 1 million Polish refugees fled eastward behind Russian lines during the war."
hague1cmaeron   
24 Jan 2011
History / Poland obliged to make war reparations to Austria and Germany after WWI. Why? [119]

but to third countries for the land they had taken over from Austria and Germany.

could you elaborate a bit further? Do you mean that Poland had to pay for the Germans found on Polish territory? I can't seem to find any information on this besides Zamoyski. That is why I found his claim so surprising.

The Treaty of Versaille decided that in 1919.

Yes but they had quite a good idea that it would come about by the end, and whilst I think that Zamoyski exaggerates, there in no doubt that it did happen, The Russians used a similar tactic. often the Russians and Germans used such tactics to deny each other vital resources.
hague1cmaeron   
24 Jan 2011
Travel / A business trip from Warsaw to Bialystok - transportation? [26]

You got to love that country! Especially the bushveld in the north!

Phalaborwa was my first place of residence, so Hans Merensky club was frequented quite often.

follwed by, I am not sure if this is exactly the right order:

Burgersfort, where rugby was compulsory in school.

Kelrksdorp

Lime Acres

Orkney

I grew to love the country, especially its close proximity to nature. I hope its all working out for you in Poland.

Re: Train and bus stations in Bialystok
Are the train station and bus station far apart in Bialystok? I am planning to transfer from Eurolines bus to train there, so long walk or short?

It's a short walk (you can see the bus station from the train station), but I can't give you the precise distance.
hague1cmaeron   
24 Jan 2011
History / Poland obliged to make war reparations to Austria and Germany after WWI. Why? [119]

According to Adam Zamoyski in his book The Polish Way, page 348, Poland was obliged to pay war reparations to Austria and Germany.

Zamoyski:

“ The only solution was massive industrialisation, but this was made no easier by the fact
that in 1918 the retreating German Army had carried out a gigantic operation quaintly termed ‘the de-industrialisation of Poland; which left no factory, railway-station or bridge standing and no piece of machinery in place. The state came into being with vast debts to the allies (for equipping and arming the Blue Army and supplying armaments between 1918 and 1920), and the unbelievable obligation of making war-reparations to Austria and Germany.”

Does anybody know why?

Interestingly he also mentions that “In 1930 a Ukrainian nationalist organisation funded from Germany begun a campaign of terrorism and sabotage.” p344 again I wasn’t aware that they got their money from Germany, was anybody else?
hague1cmaeron   
20 Jan 2011
Travel / A business trip from Warsaw to Bialystok - transportation? [26]

[quote=SA guy in Lodz]I live in Lodz. We are 11 south africans working and living here. Were do you live?

Over in Australia, not in Poland I'm afraid. There are quite a few South Africans over here in Auss though. I used to live in South Africa for about 8 years, predominantly in the north, and loved the place, I lived a bit in Botswana as well.

That is quite an SA presence in Lodz, it is not the prettiest as far as Polish cities are concerned, so what do you guys do in Lodz, and have you heard from any other South Africans in other cities?

What part of SA are you from?
hague1cmaeron   
17 Jan 2011
Life / How many English native speakers in Poland? [28]

The last few years have been quite hot in Poland, with the temperature somewhere around 35 Celsius, and coupled with the humidity that must be quite a bad combination. But i guess that was the case for a lot of other European countries.
hague1cmaeron   
17 Jan 2011
Life / How many English native speakers in Poland? [28]

Oh it is ;) It leaves you absolutely lifeless in summer!

That is the way i would describe the weather here in Australia, 2-3 days straight of 40/Celsius is not all that unusual. At least the humidity is not that bad where I live, it is mostly associated with dry heat. I guess in Poland the humidity would be more of a problem.
hague1cmaeron   
16 Jan 2011
Australia / Your new PM, A question for Aussies, and anyone living there. [20]

Your new PM,really,that voice,OMG,is it just to untrained ears or is that voice as anoyingly whingy and whiney to you guys aswell?

Yes her voice isn't the greatest is it. But as far as Labor politicians go, she is their most competent by a county mile.