PolishForums LIVE  /  Archives [3]    
   
Posts by MediaWatch  

Joined: 30 Aug 2008 / Male ♂
Last Post: 31 May 2016
Threads: Total: 10 / In This Archive: 9
Posts: Total: 942 / In This Archive: 662
From: USA, Richmond
Speaks Polish?: a little bit
Interests: History

Displayed posts: 671 / page 16 of 23
sort: Latest first   Oldest first   |
MediaWatch   
14 Jul 2010
Food / WHY IN POLAND PEOPLE DON'T USE ICE? [142]

I was told that the Poles don,t have the recipe for making it...!

Maybe you should stop hanging around idiots who hate Poles.
MediaWatch   
5 Jul 2010
News / Komorowski won Poland's presidency vote? [125]

Exactly, there are no liberals in America. They simply do not exist. In America it's the Far Right Nutjobs vs everybody else.

No liberals in America??????????

LOL!
MediaWatch   
3 Jul 2010
History / "Quiet Hero" a book on Polish Survivors rarely heard - by Rita Cosby [26]

"Quiet Hero" - a book on Rita Cosby's Polish father and Polish survivors of Nazism and Communism, is a very interesting book.

Journalist Rita Cosby does a good job bringing to light the suffering that Poles went through under Nazism and Soviet Communism, that's been rarely heard in the mainstream media until recently.

Rita also does a good job discussing America's contributions to the world and how she appreciate's being an American, since freedom and America's sacrifices should never be taken for granted.



...
MediaWatch   
1 Jul 2010
USA, Canada / A Polish Americans phone call to Rush Limbaugh [15]

Only liberals who falsely claim to be for 'the little guy', laugh at the misfortunes of others.
Liberals are the true elitists.

Many of the liberals in the Leftist media are like that. They come across like elitists.
MediaWatch   
1 Jul 2010
History / The Untold Battle of Britain [205]

On Channel 4 Now . . . .

"The story of 303 Squadron . . . "

I hope there are more shows like that.

As an American, I never heard about Squadron 303 until I read about it on the internet from other bloggers. I am glad I did and aware of it now.

303squadron.com/history.htm
MediaWatch   
30 Jun 2010
USA, Canada / Polish-American groups in Southern California [26]

I ran across this lisitng of Polish groups in southern California. Perhaps it'll be of interest to some PF-ers

Thanks for the information.
MediaWatch   
30 Jun 2010
News / Decoded talks inside Poland's president's plane are released in Internet [337]

Could someone comment on this:
My understanding of Polish is limited, but they are saying that the Yak-40 pilot heard the control tower order the descent of the presidential plane to 50m, is that right?

That's an interesting article.

The article is correct that there are too many inconsistencies with the reports of this tragedy to say that it can all be simplistically explained as because of "pilot error". Like the article said, the Russian transcripts could well be counterfeited.

According to top German experts, they think there was definitely foul play that went on. They report that the plane was given false data from the Smolensk airport. At least by the airport navigation signals that went out to the arriving plane.
MediaWatch   
27 Jun 2010
News / US shouldn't interfere in Polish election (Polish-American Advocacy Initiative) [60]

LOL!!!!!!!!!!!!!

After reading all the various opinions on this topic, all I can say is GOODNESS GRACIOUS!!! Everyone should chill out.

All this talk about Polish Americans want this candidate or that candidate to win in Poland I think is becoming a little much. I think this whole thing is much a do about nothing.

As a Polish American who reads various Polish American newspapers, I think most Polish Americans will respect the choice of whoever the Poles in Poland vote for. I know I will. All I ask for is that the next elected guy does all he can to cut taxes and promote small business in Poland. But I don't know if this position will have that big of an impact on those things.

As for the notion of any US official like Mrs. Clinton trying to influence the election, this is wrong. The US government should stay out of the Polish election. But I don't know how true this notion is.
MediaWatch   
24 Jun 2010
USA, Canada / US Polonia 70% for KaczyƄski [343]

As a Polish American I will respect either candidate that is voted in. Its up to the Poles in Poland who the best candidate is.

Having said this, which candidate would be better on cutting taxes and promoting small business in Poland?

I don't know which candidate would be best for this but who ever he is I hope he wins.
MediaWatch   
19 Jun 2010
News / Decoded talks inside Poland's president's plane are released in Internet [337]

Yes, with the assistance of precision landing systems. Unless of course, you're stupid enough (or simply uninformed) to believe that they do it blind.

You FOOL that's the whole point I have been making! In this situation, the pilot needed critical help not only from the inarticulate Russian tower guy, but from the Russian airport system communication equipment that according to German aviation experts, gave FALSE information to the plane.

MediaWatch:
Once again we don't have definite confirmation of what he actually heard or knew outside of the RUSSIAN version of things. Even the link YOU provided stated that what the Russian tower said to him could have been misintrepreted by minor changes of the inflections of the Russian sylables and word used by the Russian tower.

Also, it's not the Russian version of things, but the Polish version. MAK didn't release the transcript - Poland did. So - are the Poles liars?

The Tusk government was taking a long time to present anything to the people. The Polish people were getting suspicious that nothing was being presented to them so FINALLY the Tusk government provided the RUSSIAN transcripts to the Polish public and basically said "Yeah we think these transcripts are OK". Because Tusk wants Raproachment with Russia and doesn't want to ask too many tough questions to the Russians since naturally this would jeopardize it. But lets say in a best case scenario, to YOUR POINT, that Mr. Tusk/Polish State BELIEVES what the Russians said, that still doesn't make what the Russians said the truth. Can't Tusk and his colleagues be wrong??? Can't the Polish state be wrong???? Remember you were the one talking about those "THICKHEADED POLES". Can't the Polish state have gotten it wrong becuase they are THICKHEADED as you would say??

Even putting aside Russia in this equation, you mean to tell me that the government of ANY nation is ALWAYS accurate in how they explain a situation?

Was the US government accurate in explaining the Kennedy Assasination?
Was the Soviet government accurate in explaining the Katyn Massacre (or just about anything for that matter)?

So I guess when the government of nation (fill in the blank) gives the explanation of something we should not question it! Many Poles still have questions with this investigation.

Then you have the plane crash footage and the guy getting killed for taking that video (how can you make this up???). The airport thugs who looted the dead Poles YET we are suppose to take the WORD of their airport colleagues on the truth of what happened. For Gods sake how can people not have any questions on this whole thing?????

But NO NO NO that's ALL FINE WITH YOU!!!! Everything crazy that transpired relative to this strange tragedy I guess are all perfectly normal to you!! LOL

All the weird things happening around this whole Polish Crash tragedy during and after the tragedy, according to you, NO BIG DEAL!!!!!!!! LOL

Give me a break.

So all these strange events around this whole crash are all made up by "anti-Russian conspiracy Poles?" So Poles are using KGB NKVD methods now??? LOL
MediaWatch   
19 Jun 2010
News / Decoded talks inside Poland's president's plane are released in Internet [337]

Are you suggesting that the Pilot attempted an approach through no fault of his own?

Last time I checked, they were told clearly that the conditions were dire and that Smolensk-North couldn't accept them. What made them attempt an approach in such circumstances?

Pilots land in cloudy weather all the time.

Once again we don't have definite confirmation of what he actually heard or knew outside of the RUSSIAN version of things. Even the link YOU provided stated that what the Russian tower said to him could have been misintrepreted by minor changes of the inflections of the Russian sylables and word used by the Russian tower.

Anyway, I see that you can offer absolutely no proof to back up your statements.

LOL

Look who's talking.

A so called Polish guy taking what the Russians say as the Gospel truth. Even if what they said about the crash was premature.

A so called Polish guy who doesn't even raise and eyebrow when he hears that some Russian police were looting the dead Poles. INSTEAD your FIRST reaction is defend these thug Russian police by looking around for Polish bad behavior to justify Russian bad behavior.

A so called Polish guy who seems to care more about Russia then Poland on topics outside of this one.

A so called Polish guy who seems to get an adrenaline rush a putting a microscope on anything negative about Poles in other topics.

There is no way anybody can prove anything to you, because if the source is critical of your Russia you arbitrarily dismiss it. If the source is Anti-Poland and Pro-Russia THEN you think if counts as "proof".

The only proof you show is that you have a Pro-Russia and Anti-Poland agenda here.
MediaWatch   
19 Jun 2010
News / Decoded talks inside Poland's president's plane are released in Internet [337]

Now why that pilot error occurred, that's what people are trying to figure out.

If there was pilot error, it may not be the pilot's fault.

Just like somebody driving a car crashes because they make an error when somebody throws an object at their car or oil on the road.
MediaWatch   
18 Jun 2010
News / Decoded talks inside Poland's president's plane are released in Internet [337]

I hope you have other outlets for your paranoia, other than this forum. Everytime we try to have a discussion about the actual crash, you feel the need to drown us with your anti-russian agenda. Can you stop already?

LOL

What?

Nice rhetoric.

So when I point out that somebody who 100% believes the Russian viewpoint of the plane crash - which came out only hours after the crash (which was very premature) also is quick to take the side of Russia over Poland on other issues, makes me paranoid and have an anti-Russian agenda?

Maybe you came to that conclusion because you are paranoid and have an Anti-Polish agenda.
MediaWatch   
18 Jun 2010
News / Decoded talks inside Poland's president's plane are released in Internet [337]

Yeah we see your mentality. You are so quick to make negative generalizations about Poles but agonize when anyone makes the slightest negative generalization about Russians. Even on topics other then this crash tragedy.

No surprise you keep going by the "pilot error" explanation as gospel that the RUSSIAN government reported within hours of the crash in which anyone knows was way too premature.
MediaWatch   
17 Jun 2010
News / Decoded talks inside Poland's president's plane are released in Internet [337]

I didn't know an engine had a head and elbows and could put his hand on the back of his neck. It seemed like you saw what you wanted to see. And he wasn't in the cockpit.

MediaWatch:
That's just your propagandist opinion. But if these "cranks" supported your version, then you would be saying how smart and honest they are etc.

So you think the notion of the Tusk government of wanting Raproachment with Russia doesn't play any role in dismissing tough questions about this crash?

MediaWatch:
The only thing you are relying on is your agenda of Russia is perfect and ALL the fault is with the Polish side.

That's such a callous thing to say. Its hard to believe you're even Polish for saying these things. Which I have doubts about.

We still don't know for sure that this Russian tower warned them. You keep going by what Russia and the Russian transcript said. Even your Polish link YOU provided said that the words the Russian tower guy used could have been easily misconstrued to mean different things.

Also when you read the Russian transcript of what the Polish pilot and crew said, it seemed like they spoke in BROKEN Polish. I didn't know these educated guys spoke their own language so poorly.

MediaWatch:
Dude you're pro-Russia if not Russian yourself. Why are you bending over backwards and tripping all over yourself to defend the politically correct Russian version of events? You are so dogmatic about this issue. If I was as dogmatic as you in my questioning of Russia I could even come up with even stronger opinions against the "pilot error" explanation. But you want allow even ONE IOTA of criticism or questioning of the politically correct explanation and can't see the big picture here. Any time ANYTHING is presented to counter the "pilot error" explanation you jump all over the sources and start making major reaches to discredit them.

The "pilot error" explanation was the explanation give of the crash within HOURS of the plane crash. It was what the Russians kept repeating over and over and over to get into the world media to make them blameless.

Now many Poles in Poland thought it was very odd for the Russians to say this with such certainty when the explanations of these plane crashes take weeks if not months to determine. There were Poles who felt uncomfortable about this. Now if you're going to tell me that you are in Poland and that the Poles had no problem with this hasty "pilot error" explanation from Russia then you are definitely a fraudulent Pole.

MediaWatch:
Well of course! Any kind of information that goes against your Kremlin agenda "COULD easily been a complete fabrication" But if it supported your agenda then the source would have been "reliable" according to you.

So Russian news outlets are going to criticize their own country? You questioned the Russian news sources I used to show that Kaczyinski didn't totally trust the Russian authorities investigating this crash. You steadfastly denied these sources and what Kaczyinski said, but then later on changed your mind. So maybe these sources are actually reliable afterall?

You say the "Polish State" approved the Russian transcript? Really? Who exactly? You mean that same "thickheaded" Polish state you talked about? You know. Like you say "those Poles can be thickheaded". Maybe it was the "thickheaded Polish statesmen who did that"?

MediaWatch:
Also haven't you figured out by now that most of the Polish reporting was taken by what the Russians were saying? You think these Poles working with the Russians aren't afraid? They see what happens to people who the Kremlin doesn't like LOL Like in Ukraine, Georgia, the Russian reporters in Moscow, in England, in the Polish plane etc.

Well I did make those comments with an LOL if you recall. So I only half meant them. But you would have to be naive to think there is no pressure on the Tusk government to be reluctant to ask too many tough questions on this crash. You don't think so? Most likely the whole Raproachment thing with Russia is weighing on his mind. You deny this?

MediaWatch:
Its interesting how you seem SO familiar with kavkaz. Most Poles couldn't care a less about Kavkaz or whatever you call them. But most nationalist Russians KNOW about kakvaz. HMMMMMMMM

What guy being killed in Ukraine? Most Poles don't know anything about that Kavkaz website. But for some reason YOU do. So do most nationalist Russians. Surprise surprise LOL

MediaWatch:
Yes yes it always the Polish sides' fault and with all the information coming out on this tragedy for some reason the Russians are as clean as can be. There have been questions of the Russians who operated the airport at issue and when it came out that some of the Russians (that we know of) at the airport looted the dead Poles on the plane, that means nothing to you. Nope Russia is 100% perfect blameless on this whole issue. No Russian thickheads according to you not even the Russians who looted the dead Poles. That didn't even raise an eyebrow with you. That's very strange for somebody who is Polish.

If you think I am going to defend Polish criminality you are crazy. I have already condemned Polish criminals on several occasions. And for things worse then stealing from dead bodies. But if you makes you feel better, naturally I condemn the Polish criminality that you refer to here with criminal Poles looting this Halina.

Yes we all know every nation has their criminals.

But you would think the Russians KNOWING the extreme sensitivity and international implications of this plane crash, at the very least, would have their most HONEST people providing security to this Polish crash site. But that's just fine with you. Why when you first heard that, like any regular person, you start looking for bad behavior elsewhere to JUSTIFY Russian bad behavior. And at a Polish crash site NEAR KATYN of all places!!!

I find it very interesting in your conversations, that when their is criticism of Russians, like of those Russian thugs who looted those dead Poles, who RIGHTFULLY deserved criticism, you feel this INSTINCTIVE need to defend them. You basically angrily tell everyone in so many words that people should NOT generalize negatively about Russians because of what some bad Russians do. On other occasions, you keep talking about how people shouldn't generalize negative things about the Russians and their part in the Soviet Union (even though the Soviet Union was controlled from MOSCOW). OK that's fine. I can respect your opinion that people shouldn't generalize negative things about the Russians. Fair enough.

But what I find very interesting is how you (an alleged Pole) do the OPPOSITE with Polish people. You throw around negative generalizations about Poles all the time. You make comments about Poles like "you know how thickheaded those Poles are" NOW you make another generalization by saying "HECK EVEN KILLING PEOPLE FOR THEIR BODY ORGANS IS NOTHING NEW TO POLES" Really Poles are doing this frequently??? Would you say that about the RUSSIANS?????

Truth be told, in the last hundred years, Russians have killed many more people (including their own) then Poles ever have.

I find it interesting how, even outside this topic, your main concern is promoting/defending Russia. You have barely even said anything positive about Poles in most of your conversations. And when you do talk about Poles you disparage them.

No you have no agenda here in this forum. LOL
MediaWatch   
17 Jun 2010
News / Hollywood's War with Poland. [150]

I agree that Jews complain as much as the Poles and in that respect, as I have said before, I think that Poles and Jews are very much alike.

I can't believe I am agreeing with you, but I am. :)

Yes there are those afformentioned similarities that they have in the complaint department. lol

Truth be told, there are also many positive qualities that Jews and Poles share. Its a shame more Jews and Poles don't focus on them. Like their love of family, culture, independent mindedness, are strugglers/underdogs, etc.
MediaWatch   
17 Jun 2010
News / Decoded talks inside Poland's president's plane are released in Internet [337]

Yet again, you're questioning and insulting the integrity of the Polish professionals involved with this investigation. Yet - you know nothing about aviation and don't even live in Poland!

That's the whole point. There are many questions about at least SOME of the so called Polish professionals jointly working with the Russians. I don't live in Poland but I have relatives and friends there who are suspicious and frankly they have even stronger opinions. They're the ones who have gone as far as saying that people should watch that one powerful video tape on the Polish crash aftermath. But of course you would dismiss that. Afterall you have your Kremlin agenda you must follow.

Who said I was pro-Russia? You might notice that I'm relying on the Polish version of events. And yes, they're cranks - then again, if you're relying on them to tell you about the state of mind of Poles, then it's no surprise that you're badly misinformed.

That's just your propagandist opinion. But if these "cranks" supported your version, then you would be saying how smart and honest they are etc.

The only thing you are relying on is your agenda of Russia is perfect and ALL the fault is with the Polish side.

Dude you're pro-Russia if not Russian yourself. Why are you bending over backwards and tripping all over yourself to defend the politically correct Russian version of events? You are so dogmatic about this issue. If I was as dogmatic as you in my questioning of Russia I could even come up with even stronger opinions against the "pilot error" explanation. But you want allow even ONE IOTA of criticism or questioning of the politically correct explanation and can't see the big picture here. Any time ANYTHING is presented to counter the "pilot error" explanation you jump all over the sources and start making major reaches to discredit them.

MediaWatch:
But I'm sure they would have a lot of legitimacy with you if they were arguing for the Pro-Russian viewpoint on this matter that this crash was ALL the fault of the Polish crew and Russia was blameless! If that was the case, you would be here jumping up and down referencing these so called cranks and saying "This is what most Poles are saying about this! LOL

They wouldn't have any legitimacy regardless because the vast majority are uneducated when it comes to aviation. I haven't even bothered to read the forums (apart from the specialist aviation forums) about this - why bother, when they're mostly full of uneducated drivel?

LOL Yes more rhetoric from you. Yes Yes you have all the answers on this and anybody who has a viewpoint countering yours you just arbitrarily dismiss as "uneducated" etc. That's just propaganda rhetoric.

MediaWatch:
The source of the report that the device warning the pilot of obstacles ahead being turned off was a Russian source. So why do you say the Polish elite were saying this....unless of course they are afraid of Russia and just repeating what Russian authorities say?

From what I gather, there's a good chance that many of these Russian "sources" were fabricated by the Russian and Polish media in an attempt to boost sales/webpage views. For a start - there's the mysterious interview with the controller after the accident, which only came from one source and could easily have been a complete fabrication - especially as certain aspects of the interview contradicted the transcript. I'll wait for the Polish report to tell me what was and what wasn't turned off - but we do know for certain that the TAWS was alive.

Well of course! Any kind of information that goes against your Kremlin agenda "COULD easily been a complete fabrication" But if it supported your agenda then the source would have been "reliable" according to you.

Also haven't you figured out by now that most of the Polish reporting was taken by what the Russians were saying? You think these Poles working with the Russians aren't afraid? They see what happens to people who the Kremlin doesn't like LOL Like in Ukraine, Georgia, the Russian reporters in Moscow, in England, in the Polish plane etc.

MediaWatch:
So it looks like the Russian transcripts have a dicrepancy with the Russian Interfax and their Russian sources. Is this the discrepancy you're talking about?

Nope, that's not the one. I'm not surprised there are discrepancies though - media always jumps to conclusions and fabricates things.

There you go playing games. "You say not this one" and are still playing this childish little game about some so called disrecpancy about this whole thing. I guess these little games you play should be all the more reason to trust the validity of what you say LOL

MediaWatch:
And what's wrong with the KavKaz center? They had good information on how the Russian government set up its invasion of Georgia.

Everything is wrong with them - for a start, if they're genuine (and I have my doubts) - then they are run by Muslim fundamentalists who believe in jihad - do you really trust those people? Seriously? But this is Russia we're talking about - it is perfectly believable that they could be a disinformation source designed to discredit the Chechen cause. Hard to say - and anyway, they don't publish any information about who they are.

Its interesting how you seem SO familiar with kavkaz. Most Poles couldn't care a less about Kavkaz or whatever you call them. But most nationalist Russians KNOW about kakvaz. HMMMMMMMM

There is an issue with this - because other people involved with the delegation seem to suggest that it was the Polish side at fault. Russia hasn't commented one way or another, and we all know how thick headed Poles can be when it comes to this sort of thing. Hard to judge really - I'll wait for the Polish report on this issue. Either way, if they felt they needed a Russian navigator and one wasn't supplied, then they shouldn't have taken the risk of landing.

Yes yes it always the Polish sides' fault and with all the information coming out on this tragedy for some reason the Russians are as clean as can be. There have been questions of the Russians who operated the airport at issue and when it came out that some of the Russians (that we know of) at the airport looted the dead Poles on the plane, that means nothing to you. Nope Russia is 100% perfect blameless on this whole issue. No Russian thickheads according to you not even the Russians who looted the dead Poles. That didn't even raise an eyebrow with you. That's very strange for somebody who is Polish.
MediaWatch   
17 Jun 2010
News / Hollywood's War with Poland. [150]

How would Americans, or for that matter Europeans or Asians, have any idea what went on in the Warsaw ghetto besides from what they "learned' from Hollywood movies? .

This is true. Most people who have never been to Poland or know Poles get their impression of Poland/Poles from what they hear and see in the media and Hollywood movies. I mean its not like there is any reason for average people to think about the Poles unless someone from the propaganda organs of Hollywood or the media have gotten their attention and are focusing on the Poles.

This thread is proof that some Poles have cultivated complaining and whinging and whining to a cultural phenomena that is meeting with more and more irritation outside of PL. They really should stop doing that.

LOL. Oh please.

Nobody cares about this issue except people like you.

Poles complain like 20% as much as Jews, Blacks, Muslims, Mexicans, etc. have complained against propaganda against them and I'm sure you wouldn't say the same things about those groups. In fact you would probably say how wonderful it is that they keep complaining about perceived propaganda against them. Especially the Jews.

If you see a scene of a Dutch doctor, van Dick, injecting Anne Frank with typhus, will your reaction be, good scene - this is exactly what happened. Or perhaps a Jewish doctor?

Are you referring to one of those anti-Polish Holocaust movies where they have a character that is a terrible anti-semitic Polish doctor? I forget the name of that anti-Polish movie.
MediaWatch   
17 Jun 2010
News / Hollywood's War with Poland. [150]

Poland sees America as a land of opportunity, where money grows on trees etc.

LOL

Come on.

America as land of opportunity, yes. Money grows on trees, definitely NO.
MediaWatch   
17 Jun 2010
News / Decoded talks inside Poland's president's plane are released in Internet [337]

Oh, come on. Cranks inhabit intenet message boards, it's a widely observed phenomenon. Given that there's no way of prohibiting multiple accounts, it's very easy for a conspiracy theorist to simply register 10 names, all agreeing with each other.

You say these guys investigating are HIGHLY TRAINED PROFESSIONALS??? LOL!!!! You mean like those Russians who looted the dead Poles on the crashed plane????

Yeah those former NKVD, KGB types are just the kind of highly trained Russian professionals we want on this investigation LOL

Also how convenient of you to cast aspersions on the many people on those Polish newspaper internet message boards as "cranks" who are "registering multiple accounts" just because they are questioning this Polish crash and DISAGREE with your Pro-Russia viewpoint.

But I'm sure they would have a lot of legitimacy with you if they were arguing for the Pro-Russian viewpoint on this matter that this crash was ALL the fault of the Polish crew and Russia was blameless! If that was the case, you would be here jumping up and down referencing these so called cranks and saying "This is what most Poles are saying about this! LOL

By the way -from your link.

The source of the report that the device warning the pilot of obstacles ahead being turned off was a Russian source. So why do you say the Polish elite were saying this....unless of course they are afraid of Russia and just repeating what Russian authorities say? So it looks like the Russian transcripts have a dicrepancy with the Russian Interfax and their Russian sources. Is this the discrepancy you're talking about?

And what's wrong with the KavKaz center? They had good information on how the Russian government set up its invasion of Georgia.

Are any of these news sources OK with you?

Poland Sees Long Crash Probe
Officials CONTEST Russian Suggestion That Pilot Error Was to Blame; Captain Was 'Cool-Headed' and Experienced

June 15 Prof. Poteat comments on Polish plane crash

iwp.edu/news_publications/detail/prof-poteat-comments-on-polish-plane-crash-in-tygodnik-solidarnosc

Jaroslaw Kaczynski does not trust Russian authorities

Foreign Minister Radoslaw Sikorski said Tuesday that the Polish side withdrew from the Russian navigator on the flight to Smolensk, because the Russian side "did not want or could not" make it available.
MediaWatch   
17 Jun 2010
News / Decoded talks inside Poland's president's plane are released in Internet [337]

How do you know about EACH of these people who you say have a "NO COMPROMISE WITH RUSSIA" attitude? Did you interview each of them?

Also Poles ARE speaking out against this investigation. 64% of Poles think something is suspicious about how their government is handling this investigation WITH Russia. I just told you about how Jaroslaw Kaczynski is speaking out against the Russian probe. Are you denying that he is?

Many Poles are supicious about this Russian explanation of "pilot error" as the WHOLE cause of everything.

Authorities have so far failed to provide credible answers to the many unanswered questions that have emerged.

"Authorities as well as the controlled mainstream media were quick to blame the crash on pilot error and fog.

In addition, the rumor that Kaczynski had pressured the pilot to land and so caused the crash spread within hours in the mainstream media and was repeated without criticism even in some blogs belonging to the alternative media.

But so many new facts and evidence have emerged CONTRADICTING government accounts that officials have been forced to retract statements.

Doubts are also growing about the DNA analysis performed by labs in Russia to identify the victims, following a number of contradictory statements made by authorities."

"Forums and message board of Polish newspapers such as "Gazeta Wyborcza", "Rzeczpospolita" and "Dziennik" indicate that the majority of Polish people, in the meantime, REJECT the official account of the plane crash due to pilot error."

infiniteunknown.net/2010/04/27/polish-opposition-party-demands-international-investigation-into-plane-crash/
MediaWatch   
16 Jun 2010
News / Decoded talks inside Poland's president's plane are released in Internet [337]

Yup that sounds like something you would say.

Jaroslaw Kaczynski IS not letting anyone slide and he IS questioning the Russian probe of the Polish Crash

english.ruvr.ru/2010/06/02/8930806.html

Yes the Polish military has been part of the joint investigation and many of them are starting to question it. But they weren't going to do this early on in the investigation since they wanted to give the Russian investigators a chance.
MediaWatch   
16 Jun 2010
News / Decoded talks inside Poland's president's plane are released in Internet [337]

Lech Kaczynski appointed many many appointees. So you think every single one of them had absolute loyalty to Kaczynski? Or they couldn't have a change of heart expecially considering all the pressure on them to release something? No these people may not be lying, they just may want to "get the whole thing over with" and be the ones responsible for bettering relations with Russia, which they could not do if they keep questioning Russia (but 64% of Poles have serious questions on how their government is handling this).

Also if the Polish government ACKNOWLEDGE that the Russians did something wrong, then that puts tremendous pressure on them to do something against Russia. Maybe they don't want to go through all that? They generally want Raproachment with Russia anyway. I do to as someone of Polish ancestry, but the tough questions on this issue must first be exhausted first.

There are Russian dissidents who kind of see things the way as I do. They think the Polish government is purposely looking the other way for pro-Russia political reasons.

blogs.wsj.com/new-europe/2010/05/25/russian-dissidents-say-pola nd-naive-on-plane-crash-investigation/

Also the Polish army has been doing an independent investigation of this.
MediaWatch   
16 Jun 2010
News / Decoded talks inside Poland's president's plane are released in Internet [337]

But what data was this? The airport wasn't equipped with such devices - I mean, you're welcome to show me where in the transcript it shows that they were using such technology.

Perhaps you might want to look back at what happened on the ground for Warsaw as to why this accident happened. You do know that the Poles not only failed to request a navigator, but also failed to provide weather reports?

This transcript is ACCORDING to RUSSIA. Honestly do you think Russia would have included any information that would have incriminated itself?

Would Russia ever have provided any transcripts or information on those Russian airport "security" guards who looted the dead Poles in the crashed plane if the Poles did not have evidence that that's what they did?

Also even in the last 4 paragraphs of this Polish link you give, it said that what the airport TOWER said to the pilot was very important. It sayed the words the Russian tower sayed were vague. Small changes in pronuciation or grammar by the Russian tower could have made a world of difference in their communication to the Polish crew.

As that Polish link said, its like the difference in the meaning of "good" when using the phrases "good day" or "goodbye".

Its been claimed that the Russian airtower words of "don't land" could easily have been construed as "conditional landing" by just a minor change of the inflection of the Russian syllables or words used.

And NO most Poles did not approve of these transcripts. Especially when Russia is now refusing to hand back the black boxes.

But tell me why the German aviation experts have cast doubt on the Russian tower? Why would the do that?
MediaWatch   
16 Jun 2010
News / Decoded talks inside Poland's president's plane are released in Internet [337]

I also don't like the way my blind man analogy was brushed aside. If you have a blind man, in this case the plane in the fog, with a human helper to guide him and he walks down a manhole, who is to blame? The guide, of course, as he is his eyes. They were under a moral obligation to assist more fully.

This is a good point.

I was kind of thinking the same thing.

Like the airport people were thinking "whatever happens happens" while they just went through the motions of their duties. Which have been questioned.

According to German aviation experts, they think the airport was deliberately giving out false data to the data recievers on the airplane. I don't know if it was a deliberate thing, but I could see the airport having flaws with its plane landing data equipment used to aid the plane in.
MediaWatch   
16 Jun 2010
News / Decoded talks inside Poland's president's plane are released in Internet [337]

I agree with you. Perhaps the whole truth may come out eventually?

As you know there is a whole spectrum of opinions on what happened.

There is the politically correct version that Russia put out.... that it was ALL due to this experienced Polish pilot's "pilot error" and that the Russian airport is 100% blameless..... to..... the Russian government deliberately brought down the plane since the people on board were highly critical of the Russian government.

At the end of the day, its hard to say what exactly happened, but I do know something very strange happened, which isn't being told.

Maybe the truth is somewhere in between the extremes of "Pilot Error" and it was a "Russian government plot"? Maybe the truth is more along the lines that the Russian airport crew and their equipment screwed up, making the pilot have a difficult time? I mean we already know about the integrity (or lack of) of some of the people who worked at that airport.
MediaWatch   
16 Jun 2010
News / Decoded talks inside Poland's president's plane are released in Internet [337]

post from another forum:
This whole mess has very little to do with Polish aviation traditions, qualities of Poles as pilots, or anything like that, but everything with completely worthless politicians who made a mess of things.

Oh stop it. There is a lot more to this story then you're saying.

This talk of yours about how the Poles "didn't have a trained navigator up to the task" and how they were "not trained properly" is just your propaganda since this crew landed at this airport before with no problem. Maybe the Russian airport crew and airport should have been more up to the task? I mean Russia knew the airport was only being used for a very sensitive international event. You mean it never dawned on them to do everything humanly possible to upgrade the airport and its airport crew? Starting with not employing criminals to work at the airport?

Most of the reports and opinions on this Polish crash came from those guys at the Russian airport where the plane crashed. And we know how honest these guys are. LOL Like when they were looting the dead Poles on the plane and taking their valuables. Yeah we can trust everything those guys said about this crash LOL