PolishForums LIVE  /  Archives [3]    
   
Posts by hague1cmaeron  

Joined: 30 Mar 2010 / Male ♂
Last Post: 4 Mar 2013
Threads: Total: 14 / In This Archive: 13
Posts: Total: 1366 / In This Archive: 1083
From: Adelaide
Speaks Polish?: yes
Interests: Politics, history, cricket, African mammals etc.

Displayed posts: 1096 / page 15 of 37
sort: Latest first   Oldest first   |
hague1cmaeron   
5 Aug 2011
Law / KaczyƄski doubts the Euro currency will survive [49]

Many Poles fear the whole hyperbureaucratised EU will eventually collapse.

I would be inclined to say that it will not, however I do not see Poland joining the Euro zone until the currency stabilizes. That is why the previous date of 2012 by which time Poland was supposed to adopt the Euro is out of the window, it is more likely to 2013 at the earliest.

This is somewhat good news for me, cos it means i can visit Poland more frequently(:
hague1cmaeron   
4 Aug 2011
Travel / Warsaw Airport to Gdansk - how do you find the coach ride ? [10]

I have checked the rail timetables and it looks like a good 5.5 - 7 hour journey, departing around 15:00 and arriving late at night in Gdansk. While the train ride is doable, I am considering alternatives, say by bus. Thusfar, I have come across Polskibus.com, currently 35 PLN one way 6h10m ride departing Warsaw at 15:30.

I took that route not too long ago and it worked out well, when the train arrived, I took the taxi to the hotel-taxis usually wait for passengers at the station. My journey was closer to 5 hours.
hague1cmaeron   
2 Aug 2011
Australia / Poles influence on Australian society and culture - school assignment [9]

OK I will give it a go, although I have to say because the questions are quite general in nature the answers will me quite general in reply and probably applicable to many different nationalities.

a) Identity is a very personal thing, and many different people will manifest their identities in many different ways. Although some individuals will have variations of the same identity, most people will somewhat differ as to their identity. This is partly the result of the fact that life experience often shapes identity, and no two individuals will have identical life experiences. for instance as a Polish migrant who has lived the vast majority of his life outside of Poland I have a somewhat different identity to someone who has lived their entire life in Poland.

b) Customs are broadly similar for Polish individuals living in Poland. Most of them would be based around the catholic calendar, church holidays, saints days etc. Other customs are based around national holidays, such as Constitution day-celebrating the 3 May 1791 Constitution, the Warsaw Uprising, and independence day. Some customs tend to take on a folkloric aspect on some occasions, when individuals dress up in regional dress-Polish highlander, Krakowiak etc.

c) Values are quite personal, although if i had to generalize i would say that Poles tend to share strong family values, respect for their elders etc. Respect for the nation and a deep reverence for the sacrifice many individuals paid for Poland's independence, at various stages of Poland's history.

g) In terms of Gender, I guess they are no different to the way people express their gender here in Australia.

2) Mostly through interaction with other Poles.

3) I wouldn't say that there would be any obvious differences, apart from the fact that Australians tend to be more laid back, Poles tend to be more practicing when it comes to their religion. I guess one cultural difference that does stand out is the multicultural composition of Australia in comparison to Poland which is very homogeneous. I would also say that Australians tend to take their sport more seriously than Poles-although I am sure there are exceptions to the rule.

I hope you edit out the typos. If you have any more specific questions let me know. You will also find that if you are looking for any specific information some of the threads on this forums will be quite helpful-there is a lot of stuff covered, some of it very relevant to what you are looking for. what made you choose Poland in the first place?
hague1cmaeron   
2 Aug 2011
Australia / Poles influence on Australian society and culture - school assignment [9]

Well I live in Adelaide, but was born in Poland and recently travelled in the country-part of my family lives there, so I am very familiar with all things Polish. If you won’t to PM me with all the questions or sent me an email-if that is the format you prefer, I would very happy to answer your questions. (Unless of course the person you are looking for must reside in Poland)

Cheers.
hague1cmaeron   
31 Jul 2011
History / Poland and Orientalism [115]

This acknowledgement of past glories and civilizational triumphs does not prevent Orientalists from claiming that the Orient of the present is wild, disorderly, debased and in need of Western overlords to be properly governed, and Von Molte's comments acknowledging the past civilizational glory of Poland, several hundred years before he was writing, are exactly along these same lines.

It seems to me as though you would like to attribute to yourself a nonexistent victimhood based on a "catch all" term which was never designed in reference to the Poles. Some of the observations you attribute to the Germans, could just as well have been made by the Germans in regards to the Italians, and a 1000 years ago used by the Romans to describe the Germans-every nation has its prejudices.
hague1cmaeron   
28 Jul 2011
History / Poland and Orientalism [115]

Paul Kriwaczek who wrote of an imperial Austrian saying that states that the Orient begins on the outskirts of Vienna.

That is not a very smart quote, because it would basically mean that half of Austria would have to be oriental-can you find any serious minded Austrian who believes that is the case?

As for your observations about German views on the Poles: yes it's true they definitively viewed Poland as economically backward at the time in comparison to Germany, which for various reasons was an accurate observation, but at no point did they view them as oriental-in the true meaning of the term.

As for Von Moltke-he wasn't just any man, he was the Prussian chief of staff. And according to him Poland was one of the most civilized European states in the 15th century-not quite what you would describe as oriental is it?
hague1cmaeron   
28 Jul 2011
History / Poland and Orientalism [115]

vato loco

Back on topic: I can see how "exotic" Poland can be viewed from an Orientalist POV by the likes of the Prussian military state. But like others have already pointed out on this forum, even by 19th-century standards, Poland was the most Westernized of the Slavic nation-states, at least its urban class & intelligentsia.

Except for the fact, that is not the way the Prussian military state viewed Poland-apart from the OP's imagination, one just needs to read Prussia's military chief of Staff-Von Moltke's history of Poland to find out.
hague1cmaeron   
26 Jul 2011
News / Poland's Economy Is Booming! The EU's Success Story? [711]

Watch this video:

Nice video. Not so sure about the guy smashing that glass on his head though.
That Muller guy seems like a real character. 4 more years of steady as she goes government from PO and keeping those PIS nutters from power should help improve things.
hague1cmaeron   
26 Jul 2011
History / Fascinating account by von Moltke-Prussian chief of Staff: Poland: A historical Sketch. [30]

He made interesting observations regarding Polish Jews

He goes on to say "Poland for a time was justly called 'the promised land' of the jews. p 20

He also makes the observation that: "We may add that the Poland of the 15th century was one of the most civilized states of Europe. It is true that the virtues of the citizens had much to atone for in the badly organised constitution of the republic, so that the moral qualities had to supply the place of good laws." p22

His observation of the Polish peasant:

"It is remarkable that the Polish peasant
enjoyed these privileges at a time when
- villeinage existed in all the rest of Europe,*
and that his slavery began when other
nations became free. Villeinage ceased in
Germany as early as the twelfth and thirteenth
centuries, except in Mecklenburg,
Pomerania, and Lusetia, which had had a
Slavonic population. Louis X. put an end to
it in France in 1315. Elizabeth emancipated
some English serfs as late as 1574. In
Bohemia and Moravia villeinage lasted till
the reign of Joseph II., 1781. In Poland it
began in the sixteenth century." p51-52.

He proceeds this quote by describing the lifestyle of the Polish peasant.
hague1cmaeron   
24 Jul 2011
News / Observations made by Her Majesty's departing Ambassador to Poland Rick Todd. [9]

British Ambassador on Poland and Poles



Read a farewell interview by Ambassador Ric Todd at the end of his four-year mission to Poland.

The diplomat told PAP that he would cherish "very good memories of Poland", especially his travels all around the country, to the seaside, to the Tatras. "I especially like Masuria and Kashubia" - he said. He stressed that what he liked best about his job was "a possibility to meet with various people - politicians, but also civil servants, businessmen, local government officials, representatives of the third sector and ordinary people. It was a big pleasure for me."

I have to say nobody can fault his frankness, what are your views on the ambassadors' observations?

And some other observations-less roseier than the ones edited by the moderator "Ambassador Todd - as he admits - did not like two things in Poland: that Poles don't clean up after their pets and that there is "a small group of people, often very rich or holding important positions, who think that they are above the law." According to the diplomat, the latter aspect can be observed not only in Poland, but also in many other former socialist countries. "For example in the streets, the way some people drive and park their cars. This dates back to the era of socialism: I'm an important person and this means that I don't have to abide by the law" - he said."

"he stressed. He noted, though, that "Poles sometimes overestimate their capabilities."

"When I came to Warsaw, I wanted to change the way the British government and many British people perceived Poland." "In Britain the feeling prevailed that Poland was a complicated country, that the knowledge of this country's history could be very helpful in understanding it. To me, such way of thinking made no sense. I used to tell my colleagues that Poles indeed had a difficult language and unspellable surnames, but there was nothing particularly complicated or difficult about them. They are Europeans"

"he had never managed to convince Poles that a monument to Winston Churchill should be erected in Warsaw." You in Poland have streets named after Roosevelt, a monument to de Gaulle, but nothing dedicated to Churchill (...) There still is a common view that Britain betrayed Poland during World War II. This erroneous belief is not supported by facts, but four years is perhaps too short to change it" - he admitted with regret." (I must admit Churchill is more deserving of a statute or street name than is Roosevelt or de Gaulle)

ukinpoland.fco.gov.uk/en/news/?view=News&id=618006982
hague1cmaeron   
23 Jul 2011
News / POLAND HAS LOST 1 MILLION PEOPLE (for other EU countries) [30]

Poland is s'crewed. And here I was thinking about moving back to Poland.

With an attitude like that, the phrase that comes to mind is good riddance.....
I am sure you won't be missed.

More than one million Poles who left their homeland for other countries in the EU after 2004 won't come back to Poland

There is no way they can say that with a 100% certainty.
hague1cmaeron   
22 Jul 2011
News / Poland Parliament elections in October 2011 [944]

SLD : 19% (not a great night, but about as much as they could hope for)

If they got that, that would be a really good result for them.

It's also worth pointing out that the PO/PSL/SLD "cordon sanitaire" will make sure that PiS cannot win this election. Even if they somehow win the most votes - it's certain that the other parties will be able to form a majority in the Sejm in order to make sure that PiS stay out of power. We already saw this happen on the local and regional level.

I totally agree with that. And thank God for that.

Here is the reason for my prediction, although the poles might indicate that the PO has got a big lead ahead of the elections, the media-just to keep things interesting, will make the contest closer than it really is-because you know how much the media hates boredom. Consequently what will happen is that the media will take a less critical stance towards PIS and use some ridiculous horse racing metaphors to indicate the supposed close nature of the contest, so mentally weak and unstable people-people who are determined to be sheep and part of the in crowd, will keep on changing their mind until through sheer probability PIS will get more votes than it deserves.
hague1cmaeron   
22 Jul 2011
News / Poland Parliament elections in October 2011 [944]

Everyone should post their election night predictions, whoever wins should get some sort of recognition.

PO: 45%
PIS: 28%
SLD:14%
PSL: 6%
hague1cmaeron   
22 Jul 2011
Life / Number of foreigners in Poland? [28]

In the late 1970s 1.5 million Vietnamese were members of the communist party, that is 3.1% of the total population. At the same time in Poland 3.5 million Poles were members of the communist party, that is 10% of the total population. Care to reassess your statement?

Well the commies did win them independence from the the French, didn't they?

My approach to non EU immigration would be ideally based on the Australian points system roughly translated to in John Howard's famous words "we decide who comes to this country and the circumstances in which they come."
hague1cmaeron   
21 Jul 2011
Life / Number of foreigners in Poland? [28]

But instead of trying to protect people from a country which is very much like Poland was when Poles expected help where-ever they went, Poland works with the secret police of Vietnam and sends people back to Vietnam to suffer! It's a stain on the honour of Poland.

Except for the fact that it is not very much like Poland, Communism was imposed on the Poles, whilst in Vietnam it was mostly a homegrown product of the Vietnamese people. A bit of a difference I fancy.
hague1cmaeron   
20 Jul 2011
Life / Number of foreigners in Poland? [28]

It all seems decidedly unlikely, i guess the problem might be that either the people are not registering and making themselves known, or the government is failing to count the people registered adequately or perhaps a combination of both. My guess would be that the total number of foreigners both EU and non EU citizens would probably reach a 100 000 or more.
hague1cmaeron   
20 Jul 2011
Life / Number of foreigners in Poland? [28]

Does anybody else get the feeling that Eurostat has had the wool pulled over its eyes?

What is the methodology they use to calculate the numbers? The number of about 15 000 EU citizens does seem to be quite low.
hague1cmaeron   
16 Jul 2011
News / Military power (Poland #21 in the world) [97]

Really? Does that mean my students were cardboard cutouts? Or maybe the people under whose command that unit is.

I am a believer.

PS: the email has been sent
hague1cmaeron   
16 Jul 2011
News / Military power (Poland #21 in the world) [97]

JonnyM: There's a reason they had to install security cameras pointed at the ones guarding the tomb of the unknown soldier about 5 or 6 years ago. And it's nothing to do with slipping into the bushes with under age girls.

Go on you have caught my interest(:

So far an interesting thread hopefully i will get an answer to my earlier question {is waiting impatiently for an answer}
hague1cmaeron   
16 Jul 2011
News / Military power (Poland #21 in the world) [97]

There's a reason they had to install security cameras pointed at the ones guarding the tomb of the unknown soldier about 5 or 6 years ago. And it's nothing to do with slipping into the bushes with under age girls.

Go on you have caught my interest(: