PolishForums LIVE  /  Archives [3]    
   
Posts by Nathan  

Joined: 13 Feb 2009 / Male ♂
Last Post: 24 Aug 2014
Threads: Total: 18 / In This Archive: 14
Posts: Total: 1349 / In This Archive: 623
From: Lviv, Ukraine/Toronto, Canada
Speaks Polish?: yes
Interests: languages

Displayed posts: 637 / page 15 of 22
sort: Latest first   Oldest first   |
Nathan   
19 Aug 2010
History / Colonel Mikolaj Sciborski - unknown Polish leader of OUN [20]

Good for Mikolaj! Very unfortunate he was killed; he could have been a great example for helping Ukrainian-Polish relations during and after the war.

Absolutely. He was an incredibly intelligent man, colonel at 23!, hard-working person who would have made so much more if not killed at age of 44 by Soviet communists.

Please ignore Sokrates. He does not represent the majority of Poles, in fact he only represents an isolated, depraved, hate-mongering, and a very tiny minority of us.

He proved many times to be a pathetic zero who wastes his time in writing nonsense instead of contributing something of value. Every society has its scum - nothing you can do.
Nathan   
19 Aug 2010
History / Colonel Mikolaj Sciborski - unknown Polish leader of OUN [20]

Also an important part of ukrainian ideology is to talk about a single war

You have a very limited idea about what an ideology is. It has very little to do with discussing wars against "women and children". If you read the works of Col. Sciborski, you would understand that he was involved in developing new state foundations which would bring unity to different sides of conflict and be therefore, successful in repulsing Soviet agression, not only in Ukraine, but in Poland as well.
Nathan   
19 Aug 2010
History / Colonel Mikolaj Sciborski - unknown Polish leader of OUN [20]

would need someone from outside to write a contitution for them

Mikolaj Sciborski was born in Ukraine. So how come he is from outside? :) LOL
He was a Ukrainian of Polish decent, who did a lot of fighting for Ukrainian independance and brought some marvelous works of Ukrainian national ideology in crazy time and place like inter-war Europe and especially its Eastern part.
Nathan   
19 Aug 2010
History / Colonel Mikolaj Sciborski - unknown Polish leader of OUN [20]

Mikolaj Sciborski (aka. Рокош, Оганский, Житомирский) (1897-1941) was a Polish born in Zhytomyr (Ukraine). He was a supporter of Petliura and served in Ukrainian People's Army, where he got a colonel rank in 1920. Emmigrated to Czechoslovakia, then to France after the defeat of Petliura. He was one of the organizers of the Ukrainian League of Nationalists in the early 1920s. From 1927 a member of Ukrainian Nationalists Organization, where he was a leading political theorist. In 1929 was elected as the 1st vice-president of the organization. He wrote the following works:

"Workers and OUN" (1932)
"OUN and farmers" (1933)
"Naciokratia" (1935) - the most famous;
"Ukraine in numbers" (1940)
"Stalinism" (1940)
In 1939 under the directive of Andrij Mel'nyk (OUN leader) wrote a draft of Ukrainian Constitution. After the invasion of Nazi Germany, Sciborski went to Kijiw to organize the Ukrainian national resitance groups. He was killed by Soviet partisans in 1941.

This is some of the very limited amount of information I found on Col. Mikolaj Sciborski. He is considered one of the leading political theorists of Ukrainian nationalism of the 20th century, but unfortunately, there are not enough (if at all) either Ukrainian or Polish information on him. Usually Mikolaj Sciborski is mentioned in Russian links where he is depicted in bad light since he is an important representative of Polish-Ukrainian cooperation in anti-Russian military expansionism as well as his works served as the foundation of national state formation with its own ideology.
Nathan   
14 Aug 2010
Genealogy / Von Straski, Polish surname? [22]

STRAWSKI

Or it could have been from "Strach" - means "fear", which when "-ski" is added changes to "s".
Nathan   
11 Aug 2010
News / Poland sends firefighters to help Russia [67]

Yea Ukraine relies even more than Poland on gas from Russia

I wish my country was more diversified than it is or better to say is not. The thing is this forum is about Poland and I expressed my opinion that it would be great for Poland to find more sources of gas. If you can't pass the barrier of our discussion about Klitschko and Golota and primitively try to divert me from supporting of what you basically was saying two posts higher, then I feel really sorry for you. LOL
Nathan   
11 Aug 2010
News / Poland sends firefighters to help Russia [67]

Hopefully we'll get gas from other sources soon, Lithuania is up for it.

Really great. It is the worst thing to be dependant on one source.

It is a definite option :) However, Poland is doing quite ok for itself at the moment.

There is no however. Because if there will be not "quite ok for itself" when Russia cuts the gas off, then you, Seanus, won't be the one to dig the hole in the ground in the middle of the winter time to lay a pipe-line through your garden. It is always better to have more than one source, especially for such things as gas and oil.
Nathan   
9 Aug 2010
Language / Wymysiöeryś - forgotten language (in Poland) [5]

Really interesting, especially the Lord's prayer and lulluby.

There was a language that died out on the baltic coast only a few years ago.

What was it? Do they have any video or sound records preserved?
Nathan   
3 Aug 2010
Polonia / New Polish Portal About Germany [10]

You learn this if you work for some time in Germany.

As long as you make a wise choice, this is the fastest way to bring your country to a point Germany is in. If there is some crazy dude as a leader + arguments from some non-constructive opposition, lots of valuable time is wasted and the country regresses into a ditch.
Nathan   
3 Aug 2010
History / Give back Lwow to Poland and Kaliningrad to Germany - is it possible? [198]

Not now...no reason...but the moment you start anything...heh:)

BB, no reason to party separately then :) Swedes will be fishing them in the Baltic like herring.
*opens a can of nicely marinated Polish herrings and puts them on potato puree. BB, you are always welcome for a delicious dinner :) There will be some Danzig shnitzel and famous Peremyshel pea soup on menu. I could never refuse such warm invitation our neighbor constantly expresses.*
Nathan   
2 Aug 2010
Genealogy / Ancient placenames/names that could be in connection with Proto-Slavs, old Poles [7]

i can confirm that in Serbian language DESNA means simple `right` (in Eng.) meaning `right side` (DESNA STRANA), referring on direction.

Interesting, so you kept the old form for "right" then.

could mean `to drive out the wind` what is same as `DUNAV` that could be understand in wide sense (or in logic of ancient people) as `to blow the wind`.

Or basically, to fart ;) In Ukrainian "dunuty" means to blow (e.g. wind). And I bet in many other Slavic languages it will sound similaly.
Nathan   
1 Aug 2010
Genealogy / Ancient placenames/names that could be in connection with Proto-Slavs, old Poles [7]

Interesting topic. Here some info on some large rivers flowing in and through Ukraine:

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dnieper_River

Desna is a river in Russia and Ukraine, left tributary of the Dnieper. The word means "right hand" in the Old East Slavic language.

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Desna_River

I know that in the "Creed" prayer where Jesus Christ is mentioned sitting next to his Father to the right in Old Slavic "o desnuyu" is used. I think some Slavic nations still keep this word for the right side.
Nathan   
29 Jul 2010
News / Poland and Kresy being reunited? [162]

six of which were the size of Kiev

Which ones? Except Lomza, there wasn`t any highly developed settlements ;)

you guys were two barns and a cow.

At least cow spared. The history would be quite different if you attacked tanks while riding cows. You might have won at least and the victory would have been celebrated in Poland as ``Mad cow offensive``.
Nathan   
29 Jul 2010
News / Poland and Kresy being reunited? [162]

there was no invasion and Ukraine was a depopulated field with 2 barns and a house.

And a herd of horses, which Poles stole from Ukrainian farmers to attack German tanks.

h...we just want a peacy neighbourhood, full of prospering people with enough money to buy our stuff!

:) Nice.

Thats to say im not an enemy of Ukraine or anything

Wow!
*borrows a fat red marker from BB and marks this date in his calendar* :)
Nathan   
29 Jul 2010
History / Give back Lwow to Poland and Kaliningrad to Germany - is it possible? [198]

Ukrainian language was formed under heavy Polish influence.

Is this why all the Poles I met answer in Russian (?): "Ja nie panimaju" when I talk to them in Ukrainian ;)?

I'm sorry my sarcasm was missed. I shouldn't have even tried.

Majority of Poles have sky-rocketing IQ, that's why they can't comprehend such things as sarcasm or figurative speech.

For sarcasm one needs a brain !

Exactly ;)

Amen, my friend. Amen.

Amen for the third time ;)
Nathan   
29 Jul 2010
History / Give back Lwow to Poland and Kaliningrad to Germany - is it possible? [198]

You want me to dig up the urban map of Ukraine before and after Poles moved in?

I do. And along post a map of so-called "Polish" area in the same time frame. I am really anxious to see the process of "culture transfer" from "highly developed Poles to a wild Ukrainian tribe" ;)

There is a few interesting maps of that time:

Poland 1300

Kievan Rus

You're still wrong, the immidiate Lwów surrounding was also Polish.

How immediate? Be more specific ;) Two meters from the city wall? If in the city itself Poles made only 60% after policies of Sanation, Polonization and ethnic discrimination, then what do you expect to see in the outskirts?

Ukraine does not have a valid claim to the area, they didnt develop it, they didnt build its towns and cities, if it wasnt for Poland and to the lesser extent Russia the place would still be a wasteland

We can claim easily the cities I mentioned below, which are currently in Poland, but Ukrainians are more intelligent than that :)
Here are some excerpts on who built what:

Kievan Rus', although sparsely populated compared to Western Europe,[14] was not only the largest contemporary European state in terms of area but also culturally advanced.[15]

According to you Poles had to bring even more advancement since for ages your nation had the highest IQ in Europe. Who can argue with that? ;)

(In Kievan Rus') certain inalienable rights were accorded to women, such as property and inheritance rights.[20][21][22]

I bet Poles were running for their women with axes at that time to have sex. Guess where they run to? ;)

As birch bark documents attest, they exchanged love letters and prepared cheat sheets for schools.

Love letters and cheat sheets! I mean at the time when Poles where expressing their love to women by axes and mating bull-roars. How pathetic. My condolences to beautiful Polish women to have to deal with these wild boars.

The economic development of Kievan Rus may be translated into demographic statistics. Around 1200, Kiev had a population of 50,000, Novgorod and Chernigov both had around 30,000.[23] Constantinople had population of about 400,000 around 1180.[24] The Soviet scholar Mikhail Tikhomirov calculated that Kievan Rus' on the eve of the Mongol invasion had around 300 urban centers.[25]

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kievan_Rus

Show me population of Warsaw in 1200 ;)
Also look at the maps above and tell me who built these cities where Poles haven't even put their foot in yet and Russian state didn't exist? Peremyshel', Kholm and Jaroslawl were not built by Poles, but by Ukrainians (called Rusins at that time), but these cities are in Poland now. Ukraine doesn't claim them, so be happy to hold them.

who's national birth-date is set on about 1848!

Give the source of this "set birth date" of my nation?

whereas Ukrainian first state arisen in 1991.

Be kind to provide a single source stating that Ukrainian state "first arisen" in 1991.

Let Assume for a moment that Ukrainians are in some spiritual way progeny of Kievan Rus - which is not true!

Well, world-renowned encyclopedia states otherwise:

According to the Encyclopædia Britannica, Ukrainian is a lineal descendant of the colloquial language of Kievan Rus'.[28]

Well, it is not Encyclopedia Lomżanika, of course, which has the world's greatest recognition, but still it means something :)
And at the end there is some info on ways Poles made the majority in L`viv:

At the same time, the Polish government reduced the rights of the local Ukrainians, closing down many of the Ukrainian schools.[3] or turning them into bilingual Ukrainian-Polish ones that were, in effect, Polish. Increased Polish settlement reduced the relative percentage of the Ukrainian population in the city, from around 20% in 1910 to less than 12% by 1931. At the university, all Ukrainian departments that had opened during the period of AUSTRIAN RULE !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! were closed save for one, the 1848 Department of Ruthenian Language and Literature, whose chair position was allowed to remain vacant until 1927 before being filled by an ethnic Pole (How would you call that BS?).[4] Most Ukrainian professors were fired, and entrance of ethnic Ukrainians was restricted; in response an underground university in Lwów, and a Ukrainian Free University in Vienna!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! (later moved to Prague) [5] were established[citation needed].

/wiki/History_of_Lviv

Why did I point Austria and Vienna? Because Austrians are not fukcing SLAVS and still let normal existance to Ukrainian university while SLAVS, in this case Poles, would not only close university, but fire profs and steal schools and then dare to claim: ``Oh look, the professors in L`viv were all Polish`` Yes, that`s true - you have the highest IQ in Europe, that`s why. How could I ignore that fact? ;(

And you tell me you had majority and brought ``culture`` to wild Ukrainians???? Damn, I am so happy you are out that you cannot imagine :)
Nathan   
27 Jul 2010
History / Give back Lwow to Poland and Kaliningrad to Germany - is it possible? [198]

confrontatationist

Read my post above, zając Poziomka ;) Take a deep breath and follow the instructions ;)

Good but if your people become fascist like you Poland will simply settle the issue with Russia and you'll get partitioned.

Before you wanted to do it just by yourself. What happened? Balls got curled up? ;)
Nathan   
27 Jul 2010
News / Pole loses language discrimination case in Germany; Scandalous! [97]

I have stopped reading this a long time before it reached nonsense levels and may repeat someone's else opinion. But basically, there is an old Roman sententia:

"When in Rome, live like Romans". Whatever is the law, follow it. If you don't like it, one can nowadays purchase tickets online to places where it may suit one better. So what the big deal? No money for a ticket?! People who cannot become a healthy part of society after 30 years should be deported with no right of coming back ever.
Nathan   
27 Jul 2010
History / Give back Lwow to Poland and Kaliningrad to Germany - is it possible? [198]

rather than Ukraine ceding Lviv, which had a significant Ukranian population around it even before WWII.

Absolutely.

The problem here is that the population of Lwów and its polish subburbs was 2 times greater then the surrounding Ukrainians (2 million ethnic Poles and polonised minorities as opposed to approximately a million rural Ukrainians).

Population of L'viv in 1939 is estimated at 340,000 people. Right now in 2010 it is around 800,000. Where you sucked all this 2 million BS out will forever remain a mystery :)

1900: 686,000
1925: 1,003,000
1939: 1,300,000
1945: 422,000 (September)
1950: 803,800
1960: 1,136,000
1970: 1,315,600
1980: 1,596,100
1990: 1,655,700
2000: 1,672,400
2002: 1,688,200
2006: 1,702,100[54]

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Warsaw#19th_to_20th_century

So in Warsaw there were 1.3 million PEOPLE (all nationalities) and in Ukrainian L'viv there were 2 million POLES ;) You still cannot manage 2 million PEOPLE in 2010 (70 years later) ;)

Also virtually all the towns in western Ukraine were predominantly polish

Any source, tongue-flapper? ;)

was 23% and in 1939% it was 9%

Now it is 89%, how is that? ;)

for the past 400% at no point did the Ukrainian population exceed 15%

Slow down a bit, zając Poziomka, you already measured Ukrainian population in Ukraine as 200% ;) Take a deep breath and slowly blow my di*ck out :)
Nathan   
27 Jul 2010
History / POLISH MEMORIES OF CHERNOBYL...April 26th 1986 [32]

Actually recent polls show that 200% of Ukrainians have low IQ

They must have counted by mistake you with Ironside when you two were visiting Ukraine and it dramatically lowered the whole nation's IQ together with neighboring Poland (hence 200%). Please, stay at home, don't open the door when they gather the information or again we will have a huge negative deviation in the IQ statistics.
Nathan   
26 Jul 2010
News / Pole loses language discrimination case in Germany; Scandalous! [97]

Usually when you go through divorce and there is an issue of custody a male suddenly becomes abusive, wife-beater, child-molestor, drunkard, drug-user, marichuana-over-child'-crib-smoker etc......So the child has to be "protected" from his/her father. Women have here an obvious advantage over men. So supervised visitation may often be a nice fantasy game by child's mother.
Nathan   
25 Jul 2010
News / Poland - the least liked German neighbour. [210]

Well..putting a tunnel people have to go through at something like the love parade was a recipe for desaster!

Well, no matter what you do there have to be some security measures and they often result in narrow spaces. I was at a similar situation one time - I barely came out alive. And the tragedy that happened is so unfortunate and horrible.
Nathan   
23 Jul 2010
History / Polish aristocrats - would be better off if we had Polish magnate families? [69]

I guess polish schlachta is very welcome in Ukraine.

I doesn't matter what kind of szlachta, Polish or Ukrainian. They were worthless bastards, nothing else. Some childish pricks, like Sokrates and Ironside, which cannot tolerate an opinion from others, try to point construction sites or mention Ukrainian declaration of independance as if it even slighly pertains to the subject. Of course, I have no respect to szlachta as a parasitic layer of old times community and I won't put a tattoo on my ar*se to celebrate it. It has nothing to do with Poland, Polish people in general or those who took the boots out of lazy szlachta's feet.

you even try to make Sobieski

:))) Who the hell is that? :) Some poet or painter, writer? If he wrote in Polish, I bet no one will ever claim his identity as non-Polish.