PolishForums LIVE  /  Archives [3]    
   
Posts by delphiandomine  

Joined: 25 Nov 2008 / Male ♂
Warnings: 1 - Q
Last Post: 17 Feb 2021
Threads: Total: 86 / In This Archive: 69
Posts: Total: 17813 / In This Archive: 12419
From: Poznań, Poland
Speaks Polish?: Yeah.
Interests: law, business

Displayed posts: 12488 / page 118 of 417
sort: Latest first   Oldest first   |
delphiandomine   
17 Nov 2015
News / Roman Polanski accused of unlawful sex with a minor [403]

The official story is that the judge was going to reneg on the plea bargain and send him to prison so that's why he fled.

Are these plea bargains legally binding? I've never quite understood how this works in the US.
delphiandomine   
17 Nov 2015
News / Most Poles believe current Sejm (Parliament) in Poland will be better [64]

Which paragraph of the Constitution explicitly or implicity states that a party's leader MUST BE APPOINTED PM?

What part of "honesty" and "transparency" are you struggling with today?

If so, then Pawlak, Kwaśniewski, Buzek, Krzaklewski and Belka should have all been put behind bars.

They were coalition governments, and therefore had the need to find an acceptable candidate to everyone. PiS have no such problems, hence the honest thing to do would be for Chairman Kaczyński to be PM.
delphiandomine   
17 Nov 2015
News / Most Poles believe current Sejm (Parliament) in Poland will be better [64]

Actually, I'd rather Kaczyński was just honest and became PM. It's an utter joke for the office to be held by a puppet and shows a total lack of respect for the Constitution.

I actually pity Szydło, because she's being insulted almost daily for being such a puppet.
delphiandomine   
17 Nov 2015
History / Poland's society at communism and socialism time [55]

Yes Yes. Everyone worked. Even if they didn't wanted or couldn't.

Not true in the slightest.

Because if they didn't worked, they were sent to a Gulag in the middle of Siberia.

That was only true up until the end of Stalinism.

No crime

Common myth, spread by the PRL. In fact, hooligans in football caused quite a lot of trouble, but it was all censored because the authorities didn't want to admit to having lost control.
delphiandomine   
17 Nov 2015
News / Most Poles believe current Sejm (Parliament) in Poland will be better [64]

Name someone in PiS with more political experience than Kaczyński.

As much as I dislike him, Macierewicz has far, far more experience. He's been there since what, high school? Kaczyński only entered politics in the late 1980's.

all but defunct Platform

Erm, Polonius... I don't know how to explain this to you, but PO are still very much in control of many local and provincial administrations.

That's called democracy, Platformer democracy, that is!

Surely I'm not the only one that thinks that the Prime Minister should get more airtime than a backbencher?
delphiandomine   
16 Nov 2015
News / PKP buys Alstrom Pendolino trains for € 665 million [60]

However, what's the relationship with Poland?

The problem is that some dreamers think that Poland (with no heritage of high speed railways) could just say "right, let's build some high speed trains" and that would be that. ;) Or they could buy from Alstom, who know a thing or six about train building...
delphiandomine   
16 Nov 2015
News / Poland's PIS go back to their old ways [194]

who cares.

Caught lying and all you can say is "who cares?"

No wonder you're such a PiS lover.

they found Komorowski plundered another presidential villa.400 objects looted.even toilets and kitchen fittings were removed.

Making stuff up again?
delphiandomine   
16 Nov 2015
News / PKP buys Alstrom Pendolino trains for € 665 million [60]

Compare trains in France and in ... GB ;)

...Don't do it ;)

I know quite a bit about the French network, and the problem is that almost everything was thrown at the TGV network. It's undeniably the best high speed network in Europe and no-one else even comes close, and I absolutely respect the French for what they've done with it. But the local trains in some areas along with some of the "intercites" network is falling to bits - thelocal.fr/20150526/france-set-to-scrap-several-train-lines. It's not only France that has this problem - I could talk all day about how utterly unsuitable some of the rolling stock is in the UK.

But don't worry - the TGV network is still jaw-droppingly great, and I love the way that SNCF has made the TGV network available to everyone by offering deeply discounted tickets to senior citizens and so on. It's a huge difference to the UK and Germany for instance.
delphiandomine   
16 Nov 2015
News / Poland's PIS go back to their old ways [194]

even less voted for the previous one. this didnt seem to bother you before.

More lies.

2011 election :

PO : 5,629,773
PSL : 1,201,628

2015 election :

PiS : 5,711,687

By simple mathematics, 1,119,714 more Poles voted for the last government.
delphiandomine   
16 Nov 2015
Study / For a student in Poland - how do they do internship? [26]

and then a bunch of them leave for the West anyway.

I actually support the Hungarian solution to this - if you leave, you get a huge tax bill to pay for the cost of your studies.

It's always struck me as absolutely unfair that we pay for 17-18 years of education for someone, only for a foreign country to take full advantage of it.
delphiandomine   
16 Nov 2015
News / PKP buys Alstrom Pendolino trains for € 665 million [60]

Almost, because Pendolino tickets are not known for being cheap.

Pendolino tickets can be had for 59zł in advance. I've just checked the Cesky Drahy website and the cheapest Pendolino tickets are about 50zł in advance, so broadly comparable.

And they have the tilting Pendolinos.

There are several factors : Cesky Drahy has huge competition, not only from intercity buses but also from RegioJet. Also bear in mind that the infrastructure wasn't so destroyed in CSR as in the PRL, and also the Czechs didn't deliberately try and destroy their rail system post-1990.

The problem in Poland is not PKP Intercity itself, but rather that the unions are aggressive about blocking competition. I recall that Student Agency wanted to bring the RegioJet to Poland, but the unions here have made it very clear that they'll stop any competition. It's a shame - they really understand how to operate a railway company.
delphiandomine   
16 Nov 2015
News / Most Poles believe current Sejm (Parliament) in Poland will be better [64]

Well, given that he appears to be openly behaving as the Prime Minister anyway, I'm not so sure that he's bothered about the formal title. If you think about it, he's a genius - he doesn't care about/need the money, he doesn't have to meet all those boring people and take part in all those boring summits, but he can sit in his office and dictate the direction of the country freely.

It's quite surreal that a mere backbencher has so much media time.
delphiandomine   
16 Nov 2015
News / Most Poles believe current Sejm (Parliament) in Poland will be better [64]

He'll fire the puppet premier, take office himself and the government will once again fail.

Actually, I notice something different this time round. He seems very happy to take all the headlines and make it very clear that it's his show - before, he was trying to control things from behind the scenes, but Szydło doesn't even have a chance of gaining any popularity.

She's a lame duck, and I suspect that the second their ratings start slipping (as they will), he'll throw her out and replace her with yet another puppet.
delphiandomine   
16 Nov 2015
Life / Chiropodists in Warsaw [6]

Isn't it the general way in Poland that many professions seem to require doctors when there's absolutely no need for it?

I'm thinking about the way that Polish mothers go hysterical in the UK because they can't get access to a gynaecologist on the NHS for routine care during pregnancy, even though midwives are very highly trained in that one specific field.
delphiandomine   
16 Nov 2015
News / Most Poles believe current Sejm (Parliament) in Poland will be better [64]

Well, when you start to wonder things, usually it means that exactly the opposite of whatever you are wondering is gonna happen.

Poor you. You really have no knowledge of Poland, do you? We all saw it for ourselves - Kaczyński is all over the TV, all over the media. At 9:01pm on election night, it was Kaczyński talking for 15 minutes with barely a reference to Szydło. For the next week, it was Kaczyński, Kaczyński, Kaczyński. He was all over the right wing media - Szydło was nowhere to be seen. Even after the Paris attacks, it was Kaczyński talking and not Szydło.

Then again, we live here, we see this - you don't.
delphiandomine   
16 Nov 2015
News / PKP buys Alstrom Pendolino trains for € 665 million [60]

Polish construction companies could build more of them, and this would build polish economy

Or they would be outbid by (for instance) Romanian or Bulgarian contractors who were also able to access the tender as a result. But realistically, you need the deposit to make sure that the state doesn't lose by companies artifically dumping prices. Alpine of Austria were notorious for doing this - they would offer ridiculously low prices, win the contract, then try and force the government to support them by threatening to walk off the job. Poland took a strong view and said "fine, walk" and spent the deposits running the tenders again.

You can set up requirements in such a way that is technically fair, but in practice is designed to benefit one side.

That's absolutely illegal, especially where EU money is involved (which it is in a lot of infrastructure projects).

And those companies can return favor by employing those clever officials.

It's a nice theory, but the problem is that Poland just doesn't have the capability in many cases of doing large works by itself. You'll notice that a lot of major infrastructure projects are won by foreign companies that then subcontract the work to Polish companies - the major companies take the financial risk, while the Polish companies do the work anyway.

Also, there's certainly something very suspicious about the sudden gold rush of tenders.

Nothing suspicious there beyond common sense - PiS were/are widely known to use the TKM philosophy, which means putting all their men into positions of power regardless of the merit of the previous management. Therefore, to avoid money being lost, they were trying to ensure that projects went ahead before PiS came in and started meddling. It's the same thing that happened with the GDDKiA - the common belief right now is that a lot of roads in preparation for tenders will be scrapped in exchange for things like an S9 from Rzeszów.

They had an opportunity to replace old-fashioned tracks with modern tracks, which would support stuff like tilting trains.

Remember, you also have to maintain the lines - enabling tilt on lines is one thing, but maintaining the costly infrastructure needed is another thing.

There's a very good article here about it - lowtechmagazine.com/2013/12/high-speed-trains-are-killing-the-european-railway-network.html - Poland can keep the EIP price relatively cheap by keeping the infrastructure relatively simple. It's also worth pointing out that the tilting mechanism doesn't come cheap - and it's much more difficult to maintain.
delphiandomine   
16 Nov 2015
News / PKP buys Alstrom Pendolino trains for € 665 million [60]

Severe curves, as you know.

Yes, it's commonly said that the tilting technology would have been very useful on that line.

Some interesting discussion here about line speeds -

EIC Premium run on regular lines modernised or being modernised to various speeds. The Zawiercie - Grodzisk Mazowiecki corridor which serves Warszawa to Kraków, Katowice and Wrocław has now 200 km/h on approximate 90 km section but it will allow that speed on whole 222 km stretch when finished. This section has superb parameters and it is envisaged that in near future speeds may be raised even up to 250 km/h.

Remaining sections from Grodzisk to Warszawa and from Psary to Kraków are / will be cleared up to 150-160 km/h while from Zawiercie to Katowice 120 km/h is possible. (cropped)

skyscrapercity/showthread.php?p=116825668

The boogeyman at the minute is very much the section between Opole and Koniecpol. Warsaw-Gdansk at 200km/h is fine, but 140km/h is just too slow for the Pendolino.

(by the way : it's called Pendolino by the manufacturer, but it's pretty much a different train to the tilting Pendolino found elsewhere)
delphiandomine   
16 Nov 2015
News / PKP buys Alstrom Pendolino trains for € 665 million [60]

* The modified Pendolinos bought by Poland are missing their signature ability.

The thing is that it also requires significant upgrading of the line to incorporate the infrastructure that allows the Pendolino to tilt. It's a very expensive undertaking, yet isn't really required on huge parts of the Polish rail network. The price of extra speed also comes at the expense of capacity, which would have a knock-on effect on PKP Cargo. So - from a transport point of view, it's no big deal. What's much more important is to get the CMK upgraded to 250km/h operation sooner rather than later.

* Their top speed is 200km/h, up from 160km/h achieved by polish trains in the 80's.

Correct, although the CMK was and is capable of operating at 250km/h if the money is spent on installing ECTS Level 2. They're getting there, but it's a hugely difficult and complicated process to change signalling. A good comparison is with the Cambrian Line in the UK, which had significant problems with signalling despite being much easier to replace. It will happen, but Poland needs to spend money elsewhere first.

For what it's worth, I think the Pendolino (or strictly speaking, ED250) is already certified for 250km/h operation.

They can't muster deposits of this size within 30 days.

That's absolutely normal. It's designed to stop companies from putting in bids that they can't really finance. It's a guarantee, not a deposit - so if the contractor fails to perform, the company can use the deposit to pay for the new tendering process. But 1-3% is easy enough to obtain if you've got a serious chance of winning the contract.

What's normal in construction is that the Polish company will enter some sort of consortium agreement with a foreign company - the foreign company will provide the capital, the Polish company provides the know-how and it generally works well.

As for rails, PKP had an opportunity to modernize them, allowing for high speed travel.

Yes, as rail has been systematically run down and neglected since the start of the 1990's. From memory, I think it was the Leszno-Głogów line that was limited to 20km/h because of how destroyed the track was. Many others needed total renewal, such as Jaslo-Zagorz in Bieszczady.

Even lines such as Wrocław-Przemyśl have had to undergo a huge, huge amount of work.

Those tenders have to be decided within 30 days, which seems designed to eliminate Polish companies.

30 days is nothing abnormal for tenders.

It's worth pointing out that Urban's NIE is not free of bias - it obviously isn't mentioning that the SLD were very much responsible for letting rail run into the ground in Poland.
delphiandomine   
16 Nov 2015
Off-Topic / Some November afternoon in Warsaw... Poland Solidarity with France [44]

Islam is causing this and not psychopaths using religion to their own twisted, psychotic purposes?

Well, Communism is a religion too, is it not? There's just something about humanity that makes a religion out of anything and then uses it to persecute others.

It's a bit OT, but I was shocked recently to discover that even Buddhists have been taking part in violence towards Muslims.

Of course, I know that, but don't you think that displaying such attitude at such moment is a bit inconsiderate?

Well, being inconsiderate and hurtful is part of their raison d'etre :) In a sense, I'm glad that Charlie Hebdo didn't do anything other than remain their usual mocking self.
delphiandomine   
16 Nov 2015
Off-Topic / Some November afternoon in Warsaw... Poland Solidarity with France [44]

In a sense, they've got a point - religion is causing all this carnage in the first place, so more religion is the least of what they want.

Bear in mind though that Charlie Hebdo is very left wing and regards religion as being nonsense.
delphiandomine   
15 Nov 2015
News / Most Poles believe current Sejm (Parliament) in Poland will be better [64]

Getting into law studies back then required good family connections. Nomeklatura, in other words.

A Strong leader,

So strong that he had to sneak off to visit the leader of the Opposition in the middle of the night. Hahaha.

well educated

Having a degree is nothing special in Poland.

that understand the people.

In the way that he said "the people are stupid if they believed my promises", like he did?
delphiandomine   
15 Nov 2015
News / Roman Polanski accused of unlawful sex with a minor [403]

Maybe you think Roman P. (that's how lawbreakers are named in the Polish media BTW) should be praised, extolled and idolised?

I'd rather we let the courts deal with it, which they have done.

Politicians shouldn't be commenting on legal cases.
delphiandomine   
15 Nov 2015
News / Roman Polanski accused of unlawful sex with a minor [403]

What makes me laugh is that the usual suspects on here were so quick to condemn and insult Polanski, but they were absolutely silent on the issue of Duda stealing from the country.
delphiandomine   
15 Nov 2015
News / Roman Polanski accused of unlawful sex with a minor [403]

Shows they are consistent and don't cherry-pick their justice, even if it means extraditing a Polish citizen who also happens to be very accomplished and talented but who is *guilty* of the crime.

You do realise that he's Jewish, which somewhat changes things in terms of who they pick on? If he was a Polish-Catholic, he would be treated in entirely the same way as the French treat him.
delphiandomine   
15 Nov 2015
Off-Topic / Some November afternoon in Warsaw... Poland Solidarity with France [44]

Ive been away for a few days so missed all this, frankly im utterly devestated at Ronda Rousey being so brutally knocked out by Holly Holm yesterday. That really p1ssed me off.

Is it just me, or did it look like Rousey had fallen to the same thing that Lennox Lewis did before the Lewis-Rahman I fight? She didn't look to be in shape at all, whereas Holm looked to be bigger and stronger even though there's only an inch between them.

the media is absolutely nailing this one. Great job.

Don't look at the German media...