Genealogy /
My grandpa was from Poland - Gresom Jopfa [44]
Jews are an ethnic group
Jewishness goes through the mothers
No, evidently
you have a lot to learn. The kind of thinking that Jews are an ethnic group and not a religious group is the same kind of thinking that occurred on
both sides leading to the Holocaust. Were you educated in the United States or in a country where myths and prejudices continue to be perpetuated to the detriment of all? Or have you bought into some contrived myth of oneness despite an education that would have taught you correctly?
Gersom may be a "Jewish name," but if it is a part of the Bible --which it is-- it's also a Christian name, like, for example, Noah, Benjamin, Samuel, David, Daniel, Elijah, Moses, Adam, Aaron, Elisha, Nathan, Solomon, Joseph, Joshua, Caleb, Jacob, Seth, Eve, Ruth, Rebecca, Rachel, Esther, Elizabeth, Susan, Sharon, et al.
Since there are no atheist names for historical reasons, they are also names of atheists.
If you're so keen on the discredited notion that Jews are an ethnic group, how can you possibly believe that the two quotes of yours above can both be correct? They can't be. Jewishness is passed through the mother in accordance with
religious dogma. If, in fact, Judaism was an ethnicity (again, discredited), that wouldn't be true - the child of such a union would be half Jewish. If Judaism is a religion and not an ethnicity, then a person cannot be Jewish because he is a descendant of Jews.
You don't all live in Israel? No kidding, I live in New York City and there are
many Jews here. Do you know what their ethnicity is? White Americans, black Americans, Middle Eastern Americans, and others. They all practice Judaism, but I can guarantee you that the black girl who lives next door whose parents came here from Ethiopia and my white Jewish friend whose ancestors have been in America longer than mine sure as heck aren't the same ethnicity.
As it happens, I have now found online my grandfather's immigration record. He came over to New York in 1937 from
Poland. What's more is that I found him by his birthday on a
baptism record for "Gersomus Jopfa, sw. Gregorius" researched in
Poland by a relative I didn't even know about before I began to look on these websites.
My grandfather Harry Juva a.k.a. Gersom(us) Jopfa was the son of Marek Jopfa & Anna Kontnik, and their parents from the
baptism record were Samuel Jopfa & Anna Spek "rustici" and Ioannes Kontnik & Anna Adamczyk "rustici." I am told "rustici" means villagers from the town of Stare
Miasteczko, which according to my relative online was destroyed in WWII but is about 11 kilometers from the city of Szczecinek.
________
What's wrong in saying Jews have big noses? Most of them have. Every ethnic group has some characteristic physical features. Try googling the pics of the people I mentioned in my previous posts, and you'll see characteristic features of Eastern European Jews.
In many cases, Jews have big noses, Africans have wide lips and Slavs have high cheeckbones. Get over it.
That is a very respectable answer and it is not as offensive when there's a good explanation to go along with it. About there being a Jewish nationality, though, there isn't. But I take your point Switezianka. If you don't mind giving an answer, what is your background? Aside from my grandfather, I am a quarter French and half Cuban.