The BEST Guide to POLAND
Unanswered  |  Archives 
 
 
User: Guest

Home / Off-Topic  % width posts: 77

"Curiosity" Lands On Mars! Huzzah! Poland's Mars Society Must Be Ecstatic.


PlasticPole 7 | 2,648
6 Aug 2012 #31
How about just start with this one, make it last twenty years, then build another and send it up? That isn't unreasonable.
Polonius3 994 | 12,367
6 Aug 2012 #32
Isn't it a crying shame to pump untold billions of the taxpayers' money into off-the-wall projetcs of this kind just so outerspace buffs can get their jollies off and filthy rich corporations can get even filthier! It could be better used to irrigate and recultivate huge populated wastelands (Ethiopia, Somalia,etc.) where millions are dying a slow death becaase of malnutrition , disease and drought.

OK, so the space gizmo contains apparatus produced in Ożarów Mazowiecki, if a Polish angle is needed here.
p3undone 8 | 1,132
6 Aug 2012 #33
PlasticPole,I agree,unless they can come up with something that can do a lot more sooner.They should design these things to be able to be able to lift off when they are done and come back and maybe be refitted for another mission;I don't think this would not be unreasonable either,I'm glad to find out that this rover makes sense.
Nightglade 7 | 97
6 Aug 2012 #34
Actually, if you knew much about NASA, you'd realise that the majority of their funding comes from the private sector - not tax payer money..

Give this a read: cracked.com/blog/5-reasons-you-should-be-excited-about-mars-today/
jon357 74 | 21,770
6 Aug 2012 #35
Isn't it a crying shame to pump untold billions of the taxpayers' money

No.

off-the-wall projetcs of this kind just so outerspace buffs can get their jollies off and filthy rich corporations can get even filthier!

The Earth won't last forever. Eventually we'll have to be able to get past the edge of the solar system. This will take a heck of a long time and we have to start somewhere.

It could be better used to irrigate and recultivate huge populated wastelands (Ethiopia, Somalia,etc.) where millions are dying a slow death becaase of malnutrition , disease and drought.

If people in the developed countries, especially the US stopped consuming so much life in the developing world would be easier. Are millions dying a slow death, by the way?
PlasticPole 7 | 2,648
6 Aug 2012 #36
PlasticPole,I agree,unless they can come up with something that can do a lot more sooner.They should design these things to be able to be able to lift off when they are done and come back and maybe be refitted for another mission;I don't think this would be unreasonable either,I'm glad to find out that this rover makes sense.

If they could figure out how to do that, they could bring back samples to study which would, perhaps eliminate the need for x amount of probes in the future.

It isn't so much about funding, because even if the funding is private, it is still sucking up money from the economy. It's more a matter of good management and avoiding waste which we, as a species, need to adopt as an attitude.
p3undone 8 | 1,132
6 Aug 2012 #37
Nightglade,I said that in a prior post.I really don't know all that much about NASA though;nor do I claim to.
Nightglade 7 | 97
6 Aug 2012 #38
I was referring to Polonius's comments about "untold billions of taxpayer money"
p3undone 8 | 1,132
6 Aug 2012 #39
Nightglade,My bad,Your post was right after mine and I hadn't read his as I was discussing with PlasticPole.
Nightglade 7 | 97
6 Aug 2012 #40
:) It's ok. I didn't quote because I thought it would be a very quick response, we both posted in the same minute :D
p3undone 8 | 1,132
6 Aug 2012 #41
Nightglade,lol,what do you think of Curious?
Nightglade 7 | 97
6 Aug 2012 #42
Quite excited. I followed it from launch and I was very happy to hear this morning that it landed. NASA noted that it's not designed to search for microbial life, which is a pity - I think that proof of the existence of life outside of Earth is of great interest to many. But each extra-terrestrial mission brings us one step closer to that. We already know a lot about Mars and its history. It's believed that 3-4 billion years ago it resembled a smaller version of earth with oceans and continents. Solar winds stripped away the atmosphere, resulting in the barren wasteland we see today. It's quite possible such an occurrence could happen to us too. Thus, any knowledge we can gain about the history of our closest neighbour (just outside of the 'habitable zone') I think could be of great importance to us.
SeanBM 35 | 5,806
6 Aug 2012 #43
Isn't it a crying shame to pump untold billions of the taxpayers' money into off-the-wall projetcs of this kind just so outerspace buffs can get their jollies off and filthy rich corporations can get even filthier!

This point is alway raised when talking about peaceful space exploration, who we are, where we came from and are we alone.

The total cost of the MSL project is about US$2.5 billion.[20]
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mars_Science_Laboratory

$10 billion spent on cosmetic procedures (2011 in the U.S alone)
caffertyfile.blogs.cnn.com/2010/03/10/10-billion-spent-on-cosmetic-procedures-despite-recession

For the 2010 fiscal year, the (U.S.) president's base budget of the Department of spending on "overseas contingency operations" brings the sum to $663.84 billion

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Military_budget_of_the_United_States
OP jasondmzk
6 Aug 2012 #44
The denial that they're searching for microbial life is just canard, to keep those that don't follow these things from getting disapointed. They are most CERTAINLY prowling for signs of life, i.e. mineral deposits, aquatic depressions, dry rivulets, etc. There's nary a penny to spare, either from NASA or her precious few moneybag donators, to waste time with frivolities. This mission was planned, rehearsed, and simulated ad nauseum, because this is the best hope there is of determining whether the building-blocks of life ever existed on Mars.
p3undone 8 | 1,132
6 Aug 2012 #45
Nightglade,I find it quite exciting as well,I don't think it's totally far fetched to think that Mars may have had forms of life that were very similar to ours,do you?
Nightglade 7 | 97
6 Aug 2012 #46
The denial that they're searching for microbial life is just canard, to keep those that don't follow these things from getting disapointed. They are most CERTAINLY prowling for signs of life, i.e. mineral deposits, aquatic depressions, dry rivulets, etc.

You misunderstand. They are, most certainly, searching for the existence of compounds. However, the rover is not equipped with technology capable of identifying microbial or fossilised microbial life.

Nightglade,I find it quite exciting as well,I don't think it's totally far fetched to think that Mars may have had forms of life that were very similar to ours,do you?

Who knows what the solar system looked like 4 billion years ago when Mars had oceans. Isn't it conceivable that the orbit of Mars was also different? Perhaps even inside the so-called 'habitable' zone. Another emerging theory out there, is that Asteroids are repositories for chemical compounds that serve as the building blocks for life. One connected theory is that similar life may have once existed on Mars, and asteroids that impacted the surface of Mars carried microbial life (which is capable of surviving in the cold vacuum of space) to Earth. If not life, then at least other compounds.

... this might be an interesting video for you.
PlasticPole 7 | 2,648
6 Aug 2012 #47
I do wonder if there was a dinosaur period on Mars like there was here, or was it very simple organisms that existed there at one time. It's not likely that Mars had life for long, though. Not like the Earth in that respect.
OP jasondmzk
6 Aug 2012 #48
the rover is not equipped with technology capable of identifying microbial or fossilised microbial life.

Au contraire! As a matter of fact, there's concern that the teflon coating on the instrumentation may interfere with the readings.
PlasticPole 7 | 2,648
6 Aug 2012 #49
Another question is, how far would you have to dig down to find evidence of life on Mars, or would the solar winds cause so much wind erosion, evidence might be closer to the surface?
Nightglade 7 | 97
6 Aug 2012 #50
there's concern that the teflon coating on the instrumentation may interfere with the readings.

If anything else, future generations will be able to cook their eggs on a non-stick utensil

Another question is, how far would you have to dig down to find evidence of life on Mars, or would the solar winds cause so much wind erosion, evidence might be closer to the surface?

Cannot even pretend to know, but there are massive dunes on Mars that are the size of mountains. Who knows what lays buried beneath them :) Curiosity is aptly named.
p3undone 8 | 1,132
6 Aug 2012 #51
PlasticPole,It's very possible and that may very well be they're thinking,because look at the size of the rover,As for life it's hard to say how long it could have been there had it existed.The circumstances for life may have come together much earlier in it's existence and may have lasted much longer than ours;It's really hard to say when we use the earth as a model..
PlasticPole 7 | 2,648
6 Aug 2012 #52
It would be so strange if they discovered oil on Mars...
SeanBM 35 | 5,806
6 Aug 2012 #53
Another question is, how far would you have to dig down to find evidence of life on Mars,

Unfortunately, due to the price tag (which people blow out of all proportions IMHO) the rovers are sent to 'safe' (or boring) landing spots to maximize the success of the mission rather than areas that could reveal more which are more hazardous.

there are massive dunes on Mars that are the size of mountains.

Exactly! :)

This is cool google Mars.
PlasticPole 7 | 2,648
6 Aug 2012 #54
The Mars daytime sky reminds me of the one here during a dust storm.
p3undone 8 | 1,132
6 Aug 2012 #55
PlasticPole,It really does and if you didn't know those pictures were from Mars you could very well think it was a picture from a dessert on earth
SeanBM 35 | 5,806
6 Aug 2012 #56
life on mars from the poland's view.
PlasticPole 7 | 2,648
6 Aug 2012 #57
There are a lot of unanswered questions SeanBM. Heh. My belief is, everything is so far apart throughout the universe, the odds of us finding a signal are so low, it's the same each one of us has of winning the jackpot in a lottery. It might take literally hundreds if not thousands of years of searching to actually come across one signal from another species and we have not been searching that long. So far.
SeanBM 35 | 5,806
6 Aug 2012 #58
There are a lot of unanswered questions SeanBM.

Possibly some unanswerable too but I'd prefer if we at least tried :)

It might take literally hundreds if not thousands of years of searching to actually come across one signal from another species and we have not been searching that long. So far.

Maybe not hundreds or thousands of years:

wow signal

Before boats, compasses and mapping it took a long time to go from Europe to the Americas or elsewhere.
Who knows what will be invented to make those vast distances short but I think we have not discovered all we can and at our current rate of technological advancement i.e. the moment you understand a new piece of technology means it's obsolete, I think it is our duty to find out.
PlasticPole 7 | 2,648
6 Aug 2012 #59
I've heard this explanation about the origins of the WOW signal:

Ehman has stated his doubts that the signal is of intelligent extraterrestrial origin: "We should have seen it again when we looked for it 50 times. Something suggests it was an Earth-sourced signal that simply got reflected off a piece of space debris."[9]

from the wiki article. So, I am not sure if that's an actual honest to goodness ET signal or just something from activity on or around Earth.
SeanBM 35 | 5,806
6 Aug 2012 #60
I am not sure if that's an actual honest to goodness ET signal

Join the club, nobody is but a man can dream can't he? :D

Personally I think that any life elsewhere will be as alien to us as life in the deep oceans, on the Hydrothermal vent, Lake Vostok of this planet.


Home / Off-Topic / "Curiosity" Lands On Mars! Huzzah! Poland's Mars Society Must Be Ecstatic.

Please login or sign-up on the main page to post in this category!