The BEST Guide to POLAND
Unanswered  |  Archives [3] 
  
Account: Guest

Home / News  % width   posts: 349

Presidential elections 2025 - the race has commenced!!!


Bratwurst Boy  8 | 12082
8 May 2025   #331
although it isn't?

It is fairly similiar....for example in Germany a new law needs the signature by the Bundespräsident, if he doesn't give it the new law can't come into existence....kinda a veto!
gumishu  15 | 6266
8 May 2025   #332
kinda a veto!

I didn't know that - it looks like this kind of veto is even stronger than the Polish counterpart since the Polish parliament can overturn presidential veto
Bratwurst Boy  8 | 12082
8 May 2025   #333
I didn't know that -

Na ja...not as strong, I think. More like a break....before the new law gets back to the Verfassungsschutz for more "proofing"! If there is no fault found then the Prez has to give his signature...so...it's not a total veto!
gumishu  15 | 6266
8 May 2025   #334
oh - so it turns out - it's not as storng as a veto from Polish president then :) - POLSKA GUROM !!!
jon357  72 | 23834
8 May 2025   #336
maybe the worlfs right wing leders nd ntionalists should just all unite and create one country for all rght wingers to live in?

Maybe a bit of Antarctica.

If they ask the U.K. nicely, we've got an island for them. It's called Gruinard and most of the anthrax spores from weapons testing on the island have probably weakened by now.
jon357  72 | 23834
8 May 2025   #337
Of course. He has good point about putting fascistic autocrats in an island. They can all get together and oppress the penguins.

That clown Braun can go and deface as many exhibitions as he likes. Assuming he's not jailed by PL now he's lost his immunity.
Przelotnyptak1  - | 725
8 May 2025   #338
@jon357

But Jon, open invitation for you, to visit, awaiting, after all, we, the rightists, are a gentlemanly kind, so the girls go first:::)))
Tacitus  2 | 1359
8 May 2025   #339
it's not as strong as a veto from Polish president then :

It shouldn't be. The Polish president is directly elected by the people and has a stronger position according to the constitution.

Although that also leaves more opportunities for the office to be exploited in the interests of the president's party, which in return can lead to a deadlock.

I generally like the Polish solution more because it gives the presidential office more of a purpose and legitimacy. But what happens if you end up with a president who is fundamentally opposed to anything the government wants to do?
jon357  72 | 23834
9 May 2025   #340
But what happens if you end up with a president who is fundamentally opposed to anything the government wants to do?

Then they're a lame duck president. Happens all the time between mid terms and presidential elections.

Better to have a King or Queen really.
Novichok  4 | 9139
9 May 2025   #341
The Polish system was created to protect post-communists from judgment and any possible retribution.

It's amazing how every system protects its own criminals.

Nobodty was executed in the US for the deaths of 58,000 Americans in Vietnam.
Tacitus  2 | 1359
9 May 2025   #342
Then they're a lame duck president.

A lame duck who can delay the forming of a new government and frustrate the political agenda of this government with his veto. Which is usually not helpful for the country.

Better to have a King or Queen really.

Why? If it is a king without any political power and with a purely ceremonial role, then you could still go with a directly or indirectly elected president.

If the king has actual power, then it is not very democratic is it?
jon357  72 | 23834
10 May 2025   #343
Which is usually not helpful for the country.

Yes. Unhelpful to say the least. Of course it depends on the system, the relationship between Head of State and Head of Government which does of course differ from country to country, however the result is usually stasis.

If the king has actual power, then it is not very democratic is it

Democracy takes many forms; there is no single model. Those countries, almost all among the most democratic, developed and stable countries in the world, who have a traditional Head of State, operate by consensus. The monarch's role is to advise, warn and admonish,. Also to make decisions, like a casting vote, if there is no consensus between politicians (usually if an election result is close or a Head of Government dies or is taken ill in office). They do this with the consent of the people, just as they have to abdicate when they lose that consent.

It works by trust and decency; in the vanishingly rare situation that is breached, there are of course mechanisms in place to mitigate it.

As you know, having a hereditary monarchy that has survived for over a thousand years is a sign that a system is working and has not collapsed through instability, dictatorship or revolution.
Bratwurst Boy  8 | 12082
10 May 2025   #344
is a sign that a system is working

A leftist monarchist! :)

I wonder if calling for another try of monarchy in Germany would be "verfassungsfeindlich"?

Calling for the end of capitalism seemingly isnt.....
jon357  72 | 23834
10 May 2025   #345
A leftist monarchist

Normal enough. Stability and fairer societies always go together.

I wonder if calling for another try of monarchy in Germany

Your last bloke wasn't that nice, however if Woodrow Wilson had pn't been able to veto the British plan to install Kaiser Bill's moderate and very popular grandson as monarch and a rallying point for t( nation, history may well have turned out very differently.
Bratwurst Boy  8 | 12082
10 May 2025   #346
history may well have turned out very differently.

....could have been very well true!
Crow  155 | 9733
10 May 2025   #347
Who needs another presidential elections. There is the new Pope!
Tlum  12 | 310
11 May 2025   #348
It was weird to watch how these presidential candidates were first introduced by the Polish media and have been heavily promoted for months before the debates. Almost all of these candidates have been pre-selected by the higher powers. It's less obvious in other countries.
Tacitus  2 | 1359
14 May 2025   #349
Trzaskowski has been the mayor of Warsaw for many years. I doubt he needed much introduction.

Home / News / Presidential elections 2025 - the race has commenced!!!

Please login to post here!