Return PolishForums LIVE
  PolishForums Archive :
Archives - 2005-2009 / Food  % width 58

What is this? Dark whisky Scottish or Polish?


OP dtaylor 9 | 823  
22 Aug 2008 /  #31
What if it turns out that a foreign company has bought the the Scottish comapny?
Polish made Scottish Whisky?
Misty 5 | 144  
22 Aug 2008 /  #32
Good question dtaylor :)

It would still have to be distilled/matured in Scotland to be called Scotch whisky though.
OP dtaylor 9 | 823  
22 Aug 2008 /  #33
Even if the recipe was sold?
tornado2007 11 | 2,270  
22 Aug 2008 /  #34
Good question dtaylor :)

good one but easily answered:

It would still have to be distilled/matured in Scotland to be called Scotch whisky though.

exaclty, even if the 'Scottish' Company was taken over by a 'Polish' company, for it to be Scottish whisky, it would still have to be made to the original patented specification. Misty is also correct as to be 'Scottish' whisky it would have to be distilled and matured in Scotland.

When you are buying a company or other business, you are not buying business really, you are buying their products, ideas, designs etc etc and this all comes in the way of patents and copyright protection. In other words you are buying 'assets' to add to your own company
Misty 5 | 144  
22 Aug 2008 /  #35
Even if the recipe was sold?

Still has to adhere to the legislation in order to be called Scotch. That's how I understand it anyway.

Scottish

Scotch, there's a difference. And I would try calling someone from Scotland "Scotch"... ;)
OP dtaylor 9 | 823  
22 Aug 2008 /  #36
Exactly tornado. One of Scotland's biggest produces of whisky is now in the hands of the polish, im not too sure but i will find out. by buying in "scottish" whisky, then maturing it in poland, they are able to lable the bottles as Scotch. in their country only. now we get into difficult patent laws. By law Scotch can only be made in Scotland. But this factory is importing scottish whisky.

That makes me angry, as a true scottish whisky lover, where do we cross the line?
This company owns Famous Grouse, one of the most famous scottish brewery's. Famous im not to concerned with, But famous own the right to Macallan...one of Scotlands most guarded secrets. A true whisky dated back to the 13th cent...and this company want to mass produce this Whisky.
Piorun - | 658  
22 Aug 2008 /  #37
This information is from their web site. It appears it’s made in Poland, and it could be under license although it did not said so. The other product they carry The Macallan single malt said it’s Distilled at The Macallan distillery in Speyside, Scotland, but this one said this.

Pierwsza polska whisky. Jest to whisky typu blended-mieszana, wytwarzana z żyta i słodu jęczmiennego z zachowaniem klasycznej szkockiej technologii. Jej ciemny, złocisty kolor zharmonizowany...

First Polish whisky. This is blended-mixed whisky, made of rye and barley malt according to the traditional Scottish technology. Its dark, has gold colour,...
OP dtaylor 9 | 823  
22 Aug 2008 /  #38
more detail into it finds out that the company is owned by absolut? who i know because i teach their board, is owned by sobieski. Macallan has been around for hundreds of years, so i dont get why they say its Polish. and why Scotch in big letters on the bottle:/
Misty 5 | 144  
22 Aug 2008 /  #39
by buying in "scottish" whisky, then maturing it in poland, they are able to lable the bottles as Scotch. in their country only. now we get into difficult patent laws. By law Scotch can only be made in Scotland. But this factory is importing scottish whisky.

So they still can't call it Scotch because it MUST be matured in Scotland for it to have such a name. They can, of course, import it AFTER it has matured in Scotland it can still legally be called Scotch.
Matyjasz 2 | 1,544  
23 Aug 2008 /  #40
Macallan has been around for hundreds of years, so i dont get why they say its Polish. and why Scotch in big letters on the bottle:/

Than it is Poltch Whiskey! ;)
Seanus 15 | 19,674  
2 Oct 2009 /  #41
I was in Makro and discussing it with a member of staff. She insists that this is a Polish whisky. They snuck the Scottish expertise in through the back door, I think.
jonni 16 | 2,482  
2 Oct 2009 /  #42
I can maybe shed some light on this.

Dark Whiskey was/is a well known Polish-made brand, on the market for some years and actually not at all bad.

They used to produce it at Polmos in Zielona Góra.

Now they import it.

So it's a Polish brand that is now imported from Scotland, for reasons of economy of scale.
szkotja2007 27 | 1,498  
2 Oct 2009 /  #43
Apparently its distilled and blended in Poland at the Zielona Góra distillery along with another called "Old Family Whisky". Both are bottled by L.W.W.G. Polmos S.A., Zielonej Górze.

Its a bit cheeky to call it "Scotch".

As Mel Gibson said - "You can take our lives but you will never take our Whisky................ Mr Suntory"
Seanus 15 | 19,674  
2 Oct 2009 /  #44
Aha, Polmos fairly spread the net wide. They have a decent rum in Galeon. I didn't try that whisky but dtaylor has I think. I just don't like the idea of dark whisky. I think I educated the Makro staff a little on what's good and what's not.

You can promote it with Scots but not as Scotch :) Sean Connery did a commercial for Suntory Zen. It was 950 yen if I remember, about a fiver. The bottle was a decent size too. As a Scot who likes whisky, I'd say it was very good value for money.
jonni 16 | 2,482  
2 Oct 2009 /  #45
They have a decent rum in Galeon

That's not at all bad. Better than the rum from Polmos Warszawa which is more of a rum flavoured vodka.

You'll notice some shops, especially supermarkets, only have the Dark with Scotch on the label, and some smaller shops still have stock from when they used to make it in Poland.

A bargain really, because it's quite drinkable.
szkotja2007 27 | 1,498  
2 Oct 2009 /  #46
As Roman Polanski would say - I like mine 12 years old and mixed up with Coke.
jonni 16 | 2,482  
2 Oct 2009 /  #47
:-))

I once drank some home-made whisky here. Bimber really, from Podlasie, but the old guy who made it used to put it in old whisky bottles and some people didn't notice. Actually rather passable.
Seanus 15 | 19,674  
2 Oct 2009 /  #48
LOL, Polański liked a little extra sth around the rim. He liked it smooth.
szkotja2007 27 | 1,498  
2 Oct 2009 /  #49
There are plenty bonded wharehouses near where I live. A typical barrel will lose around 50 litres over a ten year period of maturation. So a wee drop going missing isn't noticed.

Its fairly easy to get some "white whisky" but jeeze.....its like petrol.

A nice blend is as good as a Malt - Black Bottle isn't too bad for the price. Any whisky over 8 years is palatable. Be interesting if the Polish distillery decide to produce aged whiskies.
Seanus 15 | 19,674  
3 Oct 2009 /  #50
I'd tip my hat if they could make anything that was a patch on Chivas Regal.
sledz 23 | 2,250  
3 Oct 2009 /  #51
patch on Chivas Regal.

Nothing better Chivas as far as Scotch goes:)

Hey I found out today why the Scottish wear kilts??

Because Sheep can hear zippers...lol
Seanus 15 | 19,674  
3 Oct 2009 /  #52
Too much Grants Scotch is slowing me down but I get your joke. Good one, sledz :) :)

Chivas perhaps isn't objectively the best but it's super value for money. Perhaps the best in that department. I was born not far from the distillery so I'm a little biased :)

What on earth is a picture of the Queen doing as your avatar, fella? ;)
delphiandomine 88 | 18,163  
3 Oct 2009 /  #53
I was born not far from the distillery

You're a Keith loon?!

Next you'll be telling me how you make a pilgrimage to THE GREAT Keith Show every year :P
Barney 15 | 1,590  
3 Oct 2009 /  #54
Bimber

Anything like Poitin?
Seanus 15 | 19,674  
3 Oct 2009 /  #55
Well, Banff, but it's not that far really :) It's actually reputed to be from Aberdeen, way back in 1801.
Harry  
3 Oct 2009 /  #56
Mr Suntory has actually done some superb things with whisky. Try the 12-year old Yamazaki or the 17-year old Hibiki: both are cracking! And Japanese whisky is getting better and better, unlike Scotch: you idiots close your best distilleries down!
Ksysia 25 | 430  
3 Oct 2009 /  #57
Naturally, none of the smarties posted a link to Polmos.
of course this, of course that! ech, children...

sklep-ballantines.pl

Also in Poland, created Dark Whiskey (V & S Luxury ) . It is a blended liquor , obtained by a combination of selected species of Scotch whiskey , produced according to the standard set of V & S Luxury , according to a formula developed by Polmos Zielona Gora . Distillates to produce Dark Whiskey aging in Scotland at least 3 years . The Green Mountain is a set which is aged in oak barrels for no longer than a month , then filtered through specially selected filter media and packaged in bottles.

The distiller in Scotland, aged 3 years in Scotland whisky is bought by Polmos and blended in Poland.

'of course it's fake!, yada, yada, yada'
Seanus 15 | 19,674  
3 Oct 2009 /  #58
The proof is in the tasting. I'd rather avoid it I think.

Archives - 2005-2009 / Food / What is this? Dark whisky Scottish or Polish?Archived